shape
carat
color
clarity

BM/MOH Dilemma

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

AmberWaves

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
3,672
Hey guys, hope everyone is doing well! I have a problem, I initially wanted no MOH/BMs because I have no close women friends, or sisters. All my close friends are guys, and wouldn''t want to be in my wedding party (I asked). My fiance Paul, on the other hand, has at least two people he''d ask to be by his side. One of them, his brother, has already agreed to be Best Man. Unfortunately, I am a "Matchy-matchy" person, and I need at least ONE person to be with me. Here are my options:

1.) Paul''s sister- Leslie. She''s older than we are, with two kids who will not be in the wedding. The pro for this is, she''s more mature than any women close to be, and very good with details, and knows what being a MOH/BM entails. She can also afford her own dress and expenses. The cons are: she''s bossy, and often likes to bring Paul''s mom into things to help her out. Paul''s mom usually has her hands busy with other things, but helps out of guilt.
29.gif
I wouldn''t want my FMIL to have to do too much.

2.) My cousin, Elizabeth. The pros: she''s my cousin, and has plenty of time on her hands. The cons: she''s kinda snooty and very spoiled, she likes to have her way. I don''t think she can afford the dress and expenses, and we can''t afford to pay for them. She also lives a few hours away, and I''d doubt she could make it up here enough for fittings and parties, and whatever else needs to be done.

3.) Liz''s sister Anna. Pro: love her to death, we get along well, and she lives nearby. She also can afford the expenses, and would be available for weddingy things. Con: The family would be verrry angry if I had Anna and not Liz, because Liz and I are the same age and were very close through childhood, but grew apart later, which is why I now get along better with Anna. I can''t have Anna, but not Liz. But I don''t really WANT Liz. I don''t want to cause a problem in the family.

4.) My cousin Ashley, on the other side of the family, Pro:, She gets along well with everyone, and is a sweet girl. Con: she''s currently in college, and I fear she won''t be around enough for wedding stuff, and I don''t want her to jeopardize her classes. She''s 8 years younger than I am, and very immature. I worry she may not be able to afford the dress and expenses, and I wouldn''t want to put her out.

5.) Semi-close friend Jess: Pro: we get a long well, and she''s hilarious, could afford the expenses. Con: she''s very flaky (which I know is just her, and I can''t change it) and can''t really ever follow a plan. She''s often late, a very forgetful. She may not be available to help out with wedding stuff, and I worry about her being on time.

So, from looking at this, I realize I need close girl friends.
1.gif
But in all seriousness, this is why I''d rather have no one. But if I need one person, who would you pick? I don''t know if I can do just Leslie, or if my family would be mad I chose someone from HIS family over someone from mine. In all, she seems the most capable.

What would you do?
 
Does your inlaws side have great choices? I''d list them out if possible. Then, we can also come up with reasons why you "needed" to pick them.
 
Well, from my in-laws side, there are:

Leslie: Paul''s sister (already listed her pros and cons)

Heather: Paul''s sister in law, Pro: very mature and detail oriented. Can afford the expenses, and we are having her son be the ring bearer. Cons: she''s very busy, and hardly has time for anything. I''m not that close to her, I''m closer to Leslie. Those are all for my in-laws side.

I''m really stuck, as this is something I''ve worried about before I even got engaged. I''m just not sure. I guess I could ask Leslie, Anna, and Liz, and just see what everyone says. That way I can have Anna, but not insult Liz. I can have Leslie be the MOH and plan things, since I know Anna and Liz aren''t really good with that kind of stuff. I mean, Liz was my best friend through growing up, even though she was my cousin. We''ve both changed so much, though. Which is why it would be insulting to Liz to have Anna and not her.

Any other opinions?
 
Since you weren''t going to have one to begin with, you were probably expecting to do a lot of wedding stuffs yourself right? Assuming that is true, then I would just pick a person that you are closest to and can afford the expenses. That way you don''t have extra expenses to pay for.
 
My advice (now from experience) is to forget about making people mad, or hurting peoples feelings and pick the person that will be best in the role...has the money....wants to help out...is excited about throwing showers...bachelorette party...making toasts...etc...someone who will be supportive of you and the things you have to do to get this planned. I went the "don''t hurt anyone''s feelings" route...and it hasn''t worked out so well...It has been me doing most of everything, and the things I haven''t done myself I have had to twist arms and practically babysit to make sure they have gotten done...all the while listening to complaints...I wish I had chosen different people...
 
You don''t need to be matchy. But what about your mom or a favorite aunt?
 
Thanks everyone! Appletini, that is a good idea, about the favorite aunt or mother. And Amy, I appreciate your suggestion! At this point I think Leslie would be best for the job, as long as I can leave my MIL out of it. It''s so funny because the wedding is "our day" and I don''t want to spend it wondering if people are upset.
1.gif


qtiekiki, thanks for your advice, too, I''m going to have to go over who gets the "in".
28.gif
 
#1 Anna

#2 Leslie

Don''t ask all three hoping that 2 will say no, b/c I bet they will all be excited to be in the wedding party. I think it''s rare for women to turn down the chance to be a BM.
 
My inclination is to just ask Anna. She seems to be the one you really want and the best fit. What we found during our wedding (and confirmed with our other friends who had weddings) is that you''re gonna piss off someone no matter what. Too many conflicts and egos.
 
i have a similar situation as you and i am not even engaged yet either...no close female friends!! :) i am seriously considering that i will ask my mom when i have to pick a MOH... except i think she would be bossy.

just pick who you want which seems to be Anna, and say you wnated someone who was nearby, they should understand.
 
My MOH is going to be my best friend of 11 years-- a guy. I''ve told him he can wear a dress if he''ll be jealous of the BM''s outfits.
2.gif


Then again, I''m a wee bit contrary.
 
Thanks for all of your advice, I think I''ll ask Leslie and Anna. I really think Leslie can help out a lot, as well as Anna. I never would have imagined that THIS would be the hard part!
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top