Help matching 2 stones

[RingRingRingRingRing]

Hi! More help needed for my 5 grstone ring. You guys have unbelievably helpful and I really appreciate the feedback.

I chose a center stone (biggest of the 5) and one of two of the larger side stones of the 5 and need help picking the other of the larger side stones.

The center is an F, SI1, ACA




This is the first side stone I have picked out, F VVS2, ACA - smaller than the center stone.






Now I need help matching for the other larger side stone.

All 3 of these are also F and ACAs very very close in carat weight.

Option 1 (this one says “additional clouds not shown”):






Option 2: (this one is VVS2 and says “additional pinpoints not shown”)







Option 3: (this one VS1 and “additional clouds not shown”)

 

[RingRingRingRingRing]

Hi! More help needed for my 5 grstone ring. You guys have unbelievably helpful and I really appreciate the feedback.

I chose a center stone (biggest of the 5) and one of two of the larger side stones of the 5 and need help picking the other of the larger side stones.

The center is an F, SI1, ACA




This is the first side stone I have picked out, F VVS2, ACA - smaller than the center stone.






Now I need help matching for the other larger side stone.

All 3 of these are also F and ACAs very very close in carat weight.

Option 1 (this one says “additional clouds not shown”):






Option 2: (this one is VVS2 and says “additional pinpoints not shown”)







Option 3: (this one VS1 and “additional clouds not shown”)

Last image for last option—

 

[Kim N]

I like option 3 the best because it has the closest table size.

 

[Diamond_Enthusiast]

I like option 3 the best because it has the closest table size.

Agree, option 3 looks like the best match. Combo of table, angles, facets, crown & depth ratios all look to be a good match with the center stone. Option 3's ASET also looks cleaner to me.

 

[tyty333]

You really should let your SA help you since they can see the stones together and give you the best guidance on what matches
best. So, that's my choice.

Since these are all Super Ideal stones, they all will be beautiful (and similar). Your SA may* be able to see any slight nuances
between the stones (or not if they are all really similar). If they say they will all work, then I would probably go with the least expensive
but that's me...I would need to know prices to decide whether its worth paying for a higher clarity.