Help me choose between these diamonds

[hyunter]

Hi all, i'm looking for other opinions between these diamonds that I have narrowed my search down to in the 1.5ct range. All are priced similarly (within $1000 of each other)

I had my mind set on the F/SI1-colour diamond, however the knot and shallow crown angle has me slightly worried about durability. But this was the only diamond to score <2 in the HCA.

All diamonds are EYE CLEAN

Certificate ending #9783
Certificate: GIA
Shape: Round
Carat: 1.50
Clarity: SI1
Colour: F
C / P / S - F: EX EX EX NON
Measurement 7.38 - 7.43 x 4.43
Table: 59
Depth: 62.8
Crown Angle: 32deg
Pavilion Angle: 40.8deg
Shade / Luster: NON / EX
HCA: 1.2 - EXCELLENT - BIC

Certificate ending #1071
Certificate: GIA
Shape: Round
Carat: 1.50
Clarity: SI1
Colour: G
C / P / S - F: EX EX EX MED
Measurement 7.32 - 7.37 x 4.46
Table: 62
Depth: 60.8
Crown Angle: 33deg
Pavilion Angle: 41.4deg
Shade / Luster: NON / EX
HCA: 3.8 - VERY GOOD

Certificate ending #8698
Certificate: GIA
Shape: Round
Carat: 1.51
Clarity: SI1
Colour: H
C / P / S - F: EX EX EX NON
Measurement 7.28 - 7.32 x 4.59
Table: 57
Depth: 62.8
Crown Angle: 36.5deg
Pavilion Angle: 40.8deg
Shade / Luster: NON / EX
HCA: 3.1 - VERY GOOD

Certificate XXXX
Certificate: GIA
Shape: Round
Carat: 1.51
Clarity: SI2
Colour: F
C / P / S - F: EX EX EX NON
Measurement 7.27 - 7.32 x 4.54
Table: 558
Depth: 62.3
Crown Angle: 36deg
Pavilion Angle: 41.0deg
Shade / Luster: NON / EX
HCA: 4.8 - GOOD

 

[Kim N]

The F SI1 will return more white light than colored fire. Most people tend to prefer more balanced proportions to get equal amounts of white light and colored light return. If you provide your budget and your location, we could help you find options that are better cut with more balanced performance.

 

[lovedogs]

The F SI1 will return more white light than colored fire. Most people tend to prefer more balanced proportions to get equal amounts of white light and colored light return. If you provide your budget and your location, we could help you find options that are better cut with more balanced performance.

Agreed!

 

[DejaWiz]

What are the girdle, lowers, and stars on this one?

Certificate ending #8698
Certificate: GIA
Shape: Round
Carat: 1.51
Clarity: SI1
Colour: H