Help me to choose a ring

[Sabrina1304]

Hi there,

which of the following three Tiffany Harmony engagementrings would you choose:

1.
0.24 ct F VS1
€ 2,350.00

2.
0.25 ct G VVS1
€ 2,400.00

3.
0.26 ct F VVS1
€ 2,700.00

All three rings are 3 Ex and have no fluorescence. Since I am color-sensitive I am relatively undecided, it is the question of which ring I have more of. Since I live too far from a store, I cannot see both rings in person, especially since the stores are also closed due to Corona.

Thank you

 

[lillibear]

Do you have the dimensions?

 

[Sabrina1304]

Unfortunately, I don't have the exact dates for any of the diamonds.

I just saw a used Tiffany Harmonyring which was never worn with the following data:

0.20 ct. F VVS1
€ 1.650,00
Triple Ex
Fluorescence: none
Total Depth Percentage: 62.5 %
Table Size Percentage: 54 %
Crown Angle: 33.7
Pavillon Angle: 40.9

The result is a value of 1.1 for the HCA Cut Calculator. It says: "Low HCA Scores and bigger sizes diamonds can appear dark when viewed close up."

The sentence unsettles me a little. Would it make sense to buy this used ring? After all, it is significantly cheaper than the others from the Tiffany Score, but of course also smaller in the carat number.

 

[MsShnooks]

If it’s a used ring, is the seller very reputable and have they checked the ring over to make sure it’s in excellent condition? Other than that, the diamonds sound very similar so you’d need to see them in person to check if one sparkles more that the others. However, if they’re from Tiffany’, I’d expect them to be pretty good anyway.