shape
carat
color
clarity

Helping my MIL choose her first diamond studs--need advice and help searching

mayaINaU

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jan 1, 2021
Messages
819
Hi, hoping the experts here can help me with this very important task! @DejaWiz and @lovedogs, would appreciate your thoughts. I reached out to IDJ, gave them my parameters (sent them the Pricescope ideal proportions), but I am not really happy with the first set of choices they got back to me with. For example, this stone was suggested as part of a pair, but I don't think it will cut it (mediocre HCA score and doesn't actually fit the ideal proportions): GIA 2427999090

And, in any case, they were going to be way over budget, so we need to do some adjusting.

She wanted 2 carats total weight round brilliant earth-mined. She wanted G-I color (G would be the best but will go down to I) and we are ok with SI 1-2, and some fluorescence. Ideal cut. She would rather go down in size than down in any other specs. Budget for just the stones is $6,000. Therefore, based on what I was seeing, I am searching for approximately 1.8 carats total weight for the pair, to keep the specs and keep in budget.

I am still interested in working with IDJ, because I would rather get ASET/Idealscope images prior to buying, rather than getting the stones and doing them myself. I would be open to that if this were a purchase for me, but I don't want to risk all the back and forth on someone else's behalf.

I tried my own search, but I don't know all the tricks for doing this quickly. What about these?
H colors, .9 carats
GIA 2467039608
GIA 5456176466
GIA 6465008159
GIA 6465217615

G colors, .9 carats
GIA 5466884779
GIA 1455533343
 
@DejaWiz, do you mind if I contact you on Reddit to get some specific GIA # suggestions to ask IDJ to bring in?
 
@DejaWiz, do you mind if I contact you on Reddit to get some specific GIA # suggestions to ask IDJ to bring in?

By all means, please do!
Please use the chat feature instead of DM since DM has been broken with their last few app updates.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top