How about this one ...?

[BecomingACutNerd]

Okay, I know everyone here is tired of seeing "how about this one?" posts, but if you wouldn''t mind, could someone give their 2 cents on the value of this diamond?

Price: $4841
.90 carat
table: 55.1%
depth: 60.8%
color: G
clarity: VS2
Crown Angle: 35.2
Pavilion Angle: 40.4
Girdle: 1.6%
HCA: .6 ex-ex-ex-vg

Does anyone think that the difference between this diamond and a 1 carat would be that noticeable?
The spread is 6.22-6.29.

 

[BecomingACutNerd]

Sorry, forgot to mention that the symmetry/polish is VG/EX.

 

[niceice]

We've never been really fond of pavilion angles that shallow, but it may very well be a very pretty stone. Have you seen it?

 

[BecomingACutNerd]

Nope, I haven't seen it. I was concerned about the angles myself, but the HCA score is good. What is the effect of these borderline angles?

I guess I'm trying to stay just slightly under 1 carat but also keep a good spread. There aren't alot of those out there, it seems. I guess the cutter would rather have a lower quality 1 carat than a higher quality "not quite a carat."