shape
carat
color
clarity

Need your advice! - choosing diamond studs setting

Eugeniya

Rough_Rock
Joined
Dec 16, 2022
Messages
43
Dear PSers! I’m a bit new at this forum, and a complete newbie in diamonds. I’ve got simple diamond studs (0.85 tcw with jackets) some time ago that set in WG illusion/buttercup setting. But I’m feeling that there is too much white metal showing for my taste, especially from the front view (like studs protruding sideways). I absolutely love YG buttercup settings, but not accustomed much to wearing WG (I’m a redhead and mostly had YG). The jeweler also brought me 0.83 tcw studs in 6 prongs scalloped martini setting (not sure about exact name) with jackets to try on.
Another story is diamonds. Diamonds set in my illusion setting studs (G/VVS2) have HCA scores 2.6 and between 1 and 2 (don’t remember correctly), and GIA triple X/ AGS Ideal on diamondscreener. The new 6-prongs studs (J/VVS1-2) are GIA triple X/ AGS Ex on diamonscreener, and have large table (62%) and not good crown/pavilion angle combo (33%/41.6%). It sounds silly but I couldn’t tell much difference between them in direct comparison, maybe the latter have a slightly less fire and scintillation (but it almost indiscernible). I can see a slight difference in color G vs J but also not much. But I’m a novice so couldn’t really see the difference.
I need to choose between these two studs so I’ve decided to ask your help and advice, which type of studs looks better on me and does stones difference really matter in my case?
I’m not able to get studs from PS preferred vendors because I’m living in Myanmar and here is problems with buying from US or other countries. 2653E07B-2486-4F32-904F-E13150D269D6.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • DED93389-0365-4BFB-9075-9ED5DDEAD979.jpeg
    DED93389-0365-4BFB-9075-9ED5DDEAD979.jpeg
    84.4 KB · Views: 12
  • 1DFD6F30-A1C9-498A-820C-83ABCA1E40B2.jpeg
    1DFD6F30-A1C9-498A-820C-83ABCA1E40B2.jpeg
    67.3 KB · Views: 13
  • F0078D10-DCDD-4766-95B5-EA00BB4FF4D6.jpeg
    F0078D10-DCDD-4766-95B5-EA00BB4FF4D6.jpeg
    116.7 KB · Views: 13
  • 1EA07C7D-4A16-4CEA-9E0A-5589D4C8DC9E.jpeg
    1EA07C7D-4A16-4CEA-9E0A-5589D4C8DC9E.jpeg
    180.3 KB · Views: 16
  • AB517561-81A6-487E-8316-1E2BF6DD773D.jpeg
    AB517561-81A6-487E-8316-1E2BF6DD773D.jpeg
    249.2 KB · Views: 15
  • A6B1E04E-5043-4453-9B1B-AAB0146F9EE4.jpeg
    A6B1E04E-5043-4453-9B1B-AAB0146F9EE4.jpeg
    207.1 KB · Views: 15
  • 75F93C63-088C-48A1-BDB0-96E99424089C.jpeg
    75F93C63-088C-48A1-BDB0-96E99424089C.jpeg
    237.7 KB · Views: 15
Here are 6-prong martini and illusion setting studs on me.
 

Attachments

  • FB727BC1-5EDB-44B6-9CC9-11AE7F239043.jpeg
    FB727BC1-5EDB-44B6-9CC9-11AE7F239043.jpeg
    242.1 KB · Views: 32
  • 10786425-9C95-4D0E-B1EA-2EFF1284F6E1.jpeg
    10786425-9C95-4D0E-B1EA-2EFF1284F6E1.jpeg
    139.7 KB · Views: 33
  • 02296566-0B5F-4EC5-9F9C-364D5CB321CB.jpeg
    02296566-0B5F-4EC5-9F9C-364D5CB321CB.jpeg
    205.5 KB · Views: 32
  • 369710E2-D1C2-43DC-844E-EE8CD23450FC.jpeg
    369710E2-D1C2-43DC-844E-EE8CD23450FC.jpeg
    257.7 KB · Views: 32
Also studs with jackets- illusion settings with jackets are biggerE8E46278-6593-4DC2-914E-D0B30D654760.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • 5263A350-C683-40C0-9332-C0FB986CB2A7.jpeg
    5263A350-C683-40C0-9332-C0FB986CB2A7.jpeg
    179.5 KB · Views: 24
  • 5D3FE5B9-2048-44AD-A82D-999F78F1BA1B.jpeg
    5D3FE5B9-2048-44AD-A82D-999F78F1BA1B.jpeg
    199.8 KB · Views: 20
I've thought about resetting my current illusion setting studs in YG buttercup setting but it's not feasible because of high price of resetting. I also wouldn't be able to use my jackets in the case of resetting.
Please help me to choose which studs are better, I need to return one pair this weekend. Personally I feel that 0.83 tcw martini studs look too small on my ears but are just right size in jackets. Illusion setting studs (0.85 tcw) look bigger but maybe protruding too much and facing sideways. They also looks much bigger in jackets.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top