Need your feedbacks and advices on a Toi et Moi CAD

[cnkav]

Hello pricescopers, I need your brilliant feedbacks and advices on the project that I’m working on.
I feel the shanks look fine but the Halo melees are a bit too small at 1.2mm. I included the floral halo style that I’m after.
The jewellers thought upgrading 1.5mm size maybe too big for my finger size 5.5. Your thought?
Is there anything else that I need to make adjustments?

 

[kgizo]

Since you are in the CAD phase it should be easy for them to do a version at 1.5mm so you can see the difference. If size is a concern are you open to wearing on a larger finger?

 

[cnkav]

Thanks kgizo. I like to wear it on my ring finger. I have asked for 1.5mm and my jeweller strongly did not recommend it. Based on CAD, do you think 1.2mm melees are too small for 6.5mm stones?

 

[pinkjewel]

Based on the floral style you want I think 1.2mm are too small. However, I don't know if 1.5mm will make the ring too wide for your finger. I would ask them to make a CAD with the 1.5 for you to see what you think

 

[kgizo]

Thanks kgizo. I like to wear it on my ring finger. I have asked for 1.5mm and my jeweller strongly did not recommend it. Based on CAD, do you think 1.2mm melees are too small for 6.5mm stones?

I think the proportions of the 1.2 look really good based on the CAD. However, it does not give a floral look like your inspiration and I’m not sure how strongly you feel about that.
This says 1.2mm halo and feels a little more floral to me: https://www.earthstreasury.com/product/the-classic-prong-set-halo-engagement-ring/

Perhaps the jeweler can advise about prong placement to feel more floral or alternating with smaller melee, similar to these (that is if you like any of them):