Newbie needs help! which one looks better? opinions pls

[brina_ca]

1hi guys, Vendor sent me three, let me choose one of them. I have no idea how to read those images.
Only I know is red is the best, green and blue is okay,but shouldn't be too much.
Can you guys give some opinions about them? which one would have more brillance and light performance. Which one you prefer?
Thanks so much.

 

[JulieN]

I prefer the first one.

 

[brina_ca]

1ct/G/SI1

 

[brina_ca]

(3) 1ct/G/SI1

 

[brina_ca]

oops,Julie,you are so fast....
I edit them, so, still recommend the first one?

 

[JulieN]

Now it's the second one. But I think they are all pretty good looking.

 

[brina_ca]

Now it's the second one. But I think they are all pretty good looking.

JulieN, thanks for your response. any reasons to choose #2?

 

[tyty333]

I prefer the second one also...love your avatar pic!

Edit - I like it best because it overall looks like a nice stone. The first one looks like it has an issue with the right
side center of the ring...not sure if its the pic but it looks unusual. The 3rd one has 2 dark areas in the center
(the left and right side of the cross).

 

[brina_ca]

I prefer the second one also...love your avatar pic!

Edit - I like it best because it overall looks like a nice stone. The first one looks like it has an issue with the right
side center of the ring...not sure if its the pic but it looks unusual. The 3rd one has 2 dark areas in the center
(the left and right side of the cross).

Tyty333, good morning and thanks for your opinions.

I do love the avatar pic, What's he thinking and watching? He looks so seriously, hahaha.....

 

[brina_ca]

Bump...more feedback welcome

 

[iota15]

No. 2 looks to have the best Aset - overall great spread of red, and a good looking stone.

I also like No. 3, only because it's particular facet structure appeals to me. It might have a slight issue with a bowtie, maybe, but you can confirm this with the vendor. It has a slightly smaller culet, which again, is a personal preference.

No. 1 - is out, for me. Definitely the lowest contender of the three.

 

[Haven]

I definitely don't like #1. I like #3 the most, but it's such a personal thing--I like it just because the faceting pattern appeals to me. #2 has a very pronounced Maltese cross, and for whatever reason, I just don't love those. (I know, I know--throw things at me if you must.)

I think both #2 and #3 are probably lovely stones. Which do you prefer?

 

[brina_ca]

I definitely don't like #1. I like #3 the most, but it's such a personal thing--I like it just because the faceting pattern appeals to me. #2 has a very pronounced Maltese cross, and for whatever reason, I just don't love those. (I know, I know--throw things at me if you must.)

I think both #2 and #3 are probably lovely stones. Which do you prefer?

I prefer #2, but the only reason i like it because its centre likes a flower, totally no idea about the aset image, sounds silly