Please help choosing

[hnhn]

Hello All,

Between this GIA https://www.gia.edu/report-check?reportno=2215581446 , ASET images






and this WF https://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-4135230.htm.

Could please tell me which one is better quality? And worth to purchase?
Thank You !!!

 

[mwilliamanderson]

My vote is for the ACA for sure!

 

[tyty333]

ACA gets my vote!

 

[ringo865]

I like the proportions of the ACA better. I personally am not as big of a fan of low crown angles, like 33/13% (the ACA has 34.8/14.7)

Wondering whether internally flawless is a “requirement” or a ”nice to have”, as your color for both is J. You could get a bigger option pool if you were able to drop to VVS or even VS1, as they’d definitely still be eye clean.

Also, sorry, but the ACA is a whole mm bigger, so there’s also that ;o

 

[lovedogs]

ACA, hands down

 

[hnhn]

I like the proportions of the ACA better. I personally am not as big of a fan of low crown angles, like 33/13% (the ACA has 34.8/14.7)

Wondering whether internally flawless is a “requirement” or a ”nice to have”, as your color for both is J. You could get a bigger option pool if you were able to drop to VVS or even VS1, as they’d definitely still be eye clean.

Also, sorry, but the ACA is a whole mm bigger, so there’s also that ;o

I like to drop to vvs1 but could not find one that good.
the 2 or 3ct doesn't matter. I could take either stone and will convert to ER later if able to get a matching one.

 

[headlight]

Not even a question… Whiteflash 100%! There is no comparison. The A Cut Above always wins, but regardless that other stone is not a good stone.