Please help to choose between these 4 diamonds!

[sam_p83]

Hello -

I have finally narrowed down my search to 4 diamonds with pretty similar characteristics- excellent cut, color D and E, and clarity SI1. However, 2 of the 4 stones seem to have significant "needle", and "twinning wisps" as attached in the diagrams, although, none of these inclusions are noticeable to my (untrained) eyes, but I thought I should seek expert advice on the PS here in terms of how experts feel about the diagrams, and the inclusions.

I will really appreciate some advice in terms of if you were to choose one diamond from the 4, which one will you choose, and which ones will you avoid? Thank you so much for your advice in advance!

 

[Sakuracherry]

I cannot tell much from looking at those clarity plots. Do you have actual pictures of those diamonds and all the numbers like table, depth, crown angle and pavilion angle?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

The clarity plots are meaningless as far as choosing a stone goes. Clarity must be seen in the actual stone. Do you have magnified images of the diamonds and the idealscope images? That would be a start. Then the rest of the specs to check measurements such as table, depth, and angles.

 

[c-k]

Hello -

I have finally narrowed down my search to 4 diamonds with pretty similar characteristics- excellent cut, color D and E, and clarity SI1. However, 2 of the 4 stones seem to have significant "needle", and "twinning wisps" as attached in the diagrams, although, none of these inclusions are noticeable to my (untrained) eyes, but I thought I should seek expert advice on the PS here in terms of how experts feel about the diagrams, and the inclusions.

I will really appreciate some advice in terms of if you were to choose one diamond from the 4, which one will you choose, and which ones will you avoid? Thank you so much for your advice in advance!

I would look for diamonds in an Ideal cut with G H I color and VS2 or SI1 if eye clean to my comfort level.

As far as picking from what you posted, would need more info...lab reports, picture images and Idealscope images.