shape
carat
color
clarity

Rush to buy a ring (long)

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

southhorizon

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
18
A couple of weeks ago SO finally fessed up that, after months of searching for a ring, he didn''t know what to choose and asked me to help. We have been to a few places together and I have been to a few more on my own but I just can''t find a setting that I love. I was feeling a little down because for something this special, I want to love it (especially given how much it will cost).

To add to the pressure, SO is under some pressure to propose in the next week (not from me but from family) and wants me to find a ring this week (not just one that can be made but one that he can put on my finger). We have considered some form of diamond pave band (ie no centre stone) but don''t want something that looks like a traditional wedding or eternity band. I found one that I loved and, as it is not too expensive, I figured it would make a beautiful right hand ring if we ever decided to upgrade (although I love and am not sure I would want to change it).

But I don''t think SO loves it (too modern for this taste). He is thinking maybe earrings or a necklace as a temporary measure but to me it just doesn''t feel the same as some sort of ring (I like the idea that it would be something I would wear pretty regularly, the earrings may work but I just don''t wear necklaces often). I also think that if we don''t have a ring that we would just get more pressure from people about when we are going to get a ring.

I think part of his issue with a ring that isn''t a traditional engagement ring is that he wants me to have a big sparkly rock and is worried that people will think less of him if he doesn''t buy me one. (As we are in our mid thirties, most of our friends have pretty decent sized rocks). It isn''t an issue for me and I like the idea of a different ring but want him to love it and be proud that he has given it to me.

At the end of the day, I don''t care if he proposes with anything because it isn''t about the ring but it seems to be important to him. I just don''t want him to make an expensive mistake. I feel like all this fuss about the ring is distracting us from what the proposal is really all about and that proposal feels forced. I''m not sure what to do now - do I say something or just let him do whatever he feels comfortable with?
 
First off, congrats on your impending engagement!

Now second, the ring and the proposal should be about you and your FF, not his family! I don''t know what the reason is for "forcing" him to propose by the end of the week, but it seems silly to me, regardless. The proposal AND the ring should be special to you both, unique to you both, important to YOU BOTH. (Are you seeing a trend here???) If his family knows he''s going to propose, that should satiate them enough until he actually gets down on one knee and pops the question.

As for the ring...get something you LOVE. It doesn''t have to be "traditional". It doesn''t have to be big and sparkly! There have been MANY women on this website that have been proposed to with eternity bands, gemstone rings, etc etc etc, and each lovely lady has loved and cherished that ring.

Frankly, if you or your FF think you need to live up to something, go get a really nice big CZ from Target in Sterling Silver and wear that until you find the perfect ring! No one will be the wiser.
2.gif
My friend got proposed to with a CZ solitaire b/c her FI wanted to pick out the ring together, but the perfect situation for the proposal arose and they hadn''t even gone shopping!!! So he snuck out to Target and bought a temporary!
 
Date: 10/7/2009 8:33:19 AM
Author: vc10um
First off, congrats on your impending engagement!

Now second, the ring and the proposal should be about you and your FF, not his family! I don''t know what the reason is for ''forcing'' him to propose by the end of the week, but it seems silly to me, regardless. The proposal AND the ring should be special to you both, unique to you both, important to YOU BOTH. (Are you seeing a trend here???) If his family knows he''s going to propose, that should satiate them enough until he actually gets down on one knee and pops the question.

As for the ring...get something you LOVE. It doesn''t have to be ''traditional''. It doesn''t have to be big and sparkly! There have been MANY women on this website that have been proposed to with eternity bands, gemstone rings, etc etc etc, and each lovely lady has loved and cherished that ring.

Frankly, if you or your FF think you need to live up to something, go get a really nice big CZ from Target in Sterling Silver and wear that until you find the perfect ring! No one will be the wiser.
2.gif
My friend got proposed to with a CZ solitaire b/c her FI wanted to pick out the ring together, but the perfect situation for the proposal arose and they hadn''t even gone shopping!!! So he snuck out to Target and bought a temporary!

+1 on all of the above

This is about the 2 of you. Not his family. The ring and proposal should be special for you and FF. Even if it means his family has to wait a little longer.

You could design a ring and have it made custom. The proposal can wait. Or be done with a temporary. Or be done with the sketches. (look at the proposal ideas section to see someone who did this)
Whatever you both want.

Does his family have some reason or are they just impatient?
 
Check out the colored stones thread. Might give you some ideas of some pretties, that AREN''T diamonds.

I know several people irl that have colored stones as their erings and they are quite lovely. No one poo-poos their rings or thinks any less of them because they aren''t diamonds. The thing is.. get what makes YOU happy - don''t worry about what other people think. If they aren''t getting naked with you in private time, or contributing financially to your livelihood- in some way... than their opinions mean SQUAT.

Good luck selescting something you''ll enjoy wearing, and congrats on your pending engagement.
 
I would talk to your boyfriend and tell him you don''t want to rush into a ring you don''t love. Get engaged with a simple and inexpensive band. Maybe the Tiffany sterling silver band with the diamond in it? Here''s the link: Tiffany ring

It''s only $275 and it''s simple enough that I bet you''ll wear it a lot. It comes in yellow gold for $525 and platinum for $1100 if you''d prefer those metals. There''s no way I would rush into picking a ring in a week if I wasn''t sure what I wanted!
 
Hey there SH...any updates?
 
Thanks for your comments and for not posting before now. We have had a virus at work so not internet access for the last few days. I also feel a little sheepish because SO did a complete number on me. As of Thursday night (less than 12 hours after I posted), my gorgeous boy got down on one knee and asked me to marry him, with the diamond band I loved in hand! So sweet.

He had been pretending that he wasn''t sure about it so I wouldn''t know that he actually called the store and ordered it the second I was out of sight and got them to rush deliver it. He had me completely fooled, as you can probably gather from my original post. He said it was the only way he could maintain any element of surprise given the small window of opportunity he had to propose.

I should also say that I completely agree with your comments about the engagement being about us. It was actually a member of may family not his that was suggesting it would be "nice" if he proposed before she left to go overseas for a couple of months. I was furious because it was so unfair to him putting that pressure on him, especially when he wants to please his future in-laws. In the end, we are both really excited about how it turned out but without his patience and efforts it could have been a very different story. We have extracted some revenge (nicely) on the relevant person. Now all we need to do is to keep everyone in check while we plan the wedding.

So thankyou all for your support and I hope all the LIWs are as happy as I am now when their SO proposes.
 
Congratulations!
36.gif
36.gif
36.gif


MAN did he pull a fast one on you!!!

BUT...now you need to post pictures of your perfect ring!!!
9.gif
9.gif
 
Congratulations! Glad everything''s turned out well.
 
I''m glad it all worked out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top