SHOULD I BUY THIS OVAL?

[elliefarmer]

Thoughts would be appreciated on this oval! 1.7 Carat Oval cut diamond, D in colour, SI2 in clarity (eye clean) GIA certified multimedia/stone-multimedia.htm?stoneIds=C8DA7A17-FA9D-4B24-9F96-63766BD3A1A3&showMediaType=Video&mediaKey=QX99JES0BU

 

[tyty333]

I say no because, beyond the nice facets through the center, I think the rest of the stone is going to be "mushy".

Edit...no reason to create multiple threads on the same stone/subject. It just gets confusing. I'm going to ask
for your other thread to be removed (is still has 0 post).

Here is the little bit of extra info that was included in the other thread
-Table 58%
-Depth 65.9%
- Ratio 1.47
$23,000 NZD