This or That????

[Sparkledrops]

Please vote! Keep only one for ering.

 

[Sparkledrops]

Please vote! Keep only one for ering.

Authentic Tiffany, .70ct. Simple and sweet. Or
3 stone with a slightly larger center than the Tiffany, with .20ct sidestones in white gold vs platinum in the solitaire.

 

[freddyboston]

orig T&Co stone and papers ? and the 3 stone is unbranded ?

 

[Mooshi]

As a sucker for rainbows, I'll vote the option with the most of those, I'm guessing the 3 stone

 

[RMOO]

Assuming cut quality is similar, I like the finger coverage of the three stone. And also I am not a brand kinda gal, so Tiffany doesn’t have any allure for me.

 

[lovedogs]

I love tje classic tiffany solitaire so that gets my vote

 

[Sparkledrops]

orig T&Co stone and papers ? and the 3 stone is unbranded ?

Yes. The center of the 3 stone is GIA certified. I have paperwork on the Tiffany.

 

[jjca]

I like the center stone in the 3 ring a little better than the solitaire (I’m a sucker for a 3 stone - so totally biased).

 

[Sparkledrops]

I like the center stone in the 3 ring a little better than the solitaire (I’m a sucker for a 3 stone - so totally biased).

The center diamond is an E, ex cut, polish, symmetry, in WG.

The solitaire is an H, vg cut etc, and the setting is TDF in platinum. So luxurious feeling. It gives off more of a sparkly look, and the 3 stone is bigger flashes. I honestly can't tell a color difference.

I guess I kinda feel special wearing it and love the simplicity, but, I love a good three stone too! ---- I'm only keeping one!

 

[Sparkledrops]

As a sucker for rainbows, I'll vote the option with the most of those, I'm guessing the 3 stone

My daughter did as well

 

[MissGotRocks]

I am obviously drawn to a three stone as I have one. I love the finger coverage but I do appreciate the allure of a Tiffany ring. I love a beautiful solitaire but have not thus far been able to give up the three stone. No help here I’m afraid!

 

[OboeGal]

I am obviously drawn to a three stone as I have one. I love the finger coverage but I do appreciate the allure of a Tiffany ring. I love a beautiful solitaire but have not thus far been able to give up the three stone. No help here I’m afraid!

No help here either! I've always been drawn first and foremost to 3-stones, while I have a growing appreciation for the simple, sturdy elegance of a solitaire, especially in the Tiffany style.

 

[Sparkledrops]

I am obviously drawn to a three stone as I have one. I love the finger coverage but I do appreciate the allure of a Tiffany ring. I love a beautiful solitaire but have not thus far been able to give up the three stone. No help here I’m afraid!

Yours is one of my all-time favorites ever!

 

[Sparkledrops]

No help here either! I've always been drawn first and foremost to 3-stones, while I have a growing appreciation for the simple, sturdy elegance of a solitaire, especially in the Tiffany style.

I love them both!

 

[oncrutchesrightnow]

Since you already have it… Tiffany. You can replicate the 3-stone later in life. If you were choosing which to buy, it would be a harder choice for me personally.

 

[MissGotRocks]

Yours is one of my all-time favorites ever!

Thank you!

 

[AprilBaby]

Three stone for coverage

 

[Sparkledrops]

Thank you all! I have ordered a plain Tiffany band to wear with the solitaire. I don't think I'll be able to give up either of them right now!

 

[newtojewels]

I think the solitaire looks so perfect on you and you won't regret having the branded pieces!

 

[AllAboardTheBlingTrain]

I’d keep both rings, but I’d designate the Tiffany solitaire as my ering. I have a whole nother hand that could use some bling

 

[HS4S_2]

Tiffany!

 

[sugarcloud]

I adore solitaires so that's what I would choose for myself, but if the 3 stone has better cut diamonds it would be a tough choice!

 

[OboeGal]

I’d keep both rings, but I’d designate the Tiffany solitaire as my ering. I have a whole nother hand that could use some bling

I like how you think! This is almost certainly what I would do, too.

 

[Sparkledrops]

I love the luxurious feel of the Tiffany! I've ordered a matching band. (Preloved) The center of my 3 stone is super nice, and it looked great as a solitaire, too. It's the solitaire in my profile. The biggest difference in the two is the center of the 3 stone is an E, and .90ct. The T solitaire is .70 and H in color. I don't notice the color difference, and to be honest, I'm loving the smaller size and the simplicity. At the moment, I'm going to see how I like just wearing the solitaire set for awhile! When I'm sure, I'll keep one then get rid if the other.