shape
carat
color
clarity

What the heck is this line on my setting??

Alybetter

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Feb 13, 2017
Messages
575
I’ve had this setting, which was made with Distinctive Gem/Stuller, for a few weeks now. Just happened to notice this discolored line today. What is it? Can anyone help?

The metal is 14k Palladium white gold. Unplated. But there is this bright silvery line that seems to run through the entire shank at the bottom. B887ADEA-0EC1-489F-8FDC-A3F14B959E16.jpeg
 

Attachments

  • E6225D62-EFD9-45E3-96CF-78B60737FBC9.jpeg
    E6225D62-EFD9-45E3-96CF-78B60737FBC9.jpeg
    113.9 KB · Views: 10
  • C05DE9D0-EEE6-47B7-9F49-E660775FF4C4.jpeg
    C05DE9D0-EEE6-47B7-9F49-E660775FF4C4.jpeg
    128 KB · Views: 9
Adding that is can’t be rubbed off with a lint free cloth. And it definitely goes through the entire shank. I’ve just washed it with soap and water and dried it thoroughly with a lens cloth, and the white line goes through the entire shank and can be seen on all 4 sides of the shank.
 
Had the ring been re-sized?

DK :))
 
It looks like the ring was resized..You should never see the resizing mark..It should be flawless.
 
A resizing line is what it looks like to me.

Thank you, Karl. I’m crestfallen here. This was a custom design with Jon. It is a brand new setting. It has never been re-sized. At least, not by me and not to my knowledge. I’ve only had it a few weeks. It’s supposed to be 14k palladium white gold, but according to Vicki, Stuller didn’t stamp it correctly and it’s only stamped 14k. I paid close to $2k for this design and brand new setting and it’s apparently been re-sized already?

I’ve emailed Jon. Hoping he comes back with a good solution.
 
I just went back and looked at the photos sent to me from DG, before they shipped it out to me. The line is there. So perhaps they made the wrong size and had to correct it during the initial process of making the ring.
 
It looks like the ring was resized..You should never see the resizing mark..It should be flawless.

This is a brand new, custom-designed ring that arrived to me with this line showing.. I’m trying to temper my reaction to fit reality. I had to save for months for this setting, and I expected it to be close to perfect, especially considering the cost. So I’m pretty upset, but I’m not sure if asking for a fix is warranted?
 
Ive had a lot of resizing done and ive never seen a line
this is so disappointing for your brand new setting
 
This is a brand new, custom-designed ring that arrived to me with this line showing.. I’m trying to temper my reaction to fit reality. I had to save for months for this setting, and I expected it to be close to perfect, especially considering the cost. So I’m pretty upset, but I’m not sure if asking for a fix is warranted?

Absolutely! I’m positive Jon will fix this..
 
Oof @Alybetter I’m so sorry and I feel your pain. It does look sized to me as well. Hopefully, Jon will see that and I’d ask for a replacement tbh. Fingers crossed for you!!
 
Oof @Alybetter I’m so sorry and I feel your pain. It does look sized to me as well. Hopefully, Jon will see that and I’d ask for a replacement tbh. Fingers crossed for you!!

Thanks much.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top