shape
carat
color
clarity

White gold vs yellow gold – The Landscape has Changed, have You?

Texas Leaguer

Ideal_Rock
Trade
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
3,864
Shoppers can choose from a variety of metals for their fine jewelry depending on their preferences for appearance, characteristics, and price point. Gold is traditionally the most popular choice, and has remained so in modern times primarily because it comes in both yellow and white. But there are other choices, and it is worthwhile reviewing current trends and pricing so that you can make the best choice for your fine jewelry.

Although yellow gold was once THE metal for fine jewelry, white gold has been a staple of diamond jewelry for the past several decades. But fashion trends have an impact on metal choices and there has been a recent resurgence of yellow gold in the market in the last few years.
The simplicity and richness of yellow gold has always made it popular. It doesn’t need plating and it has that traditional look that conveys opulence. It is available in a variety of purities that provide for affordability and durability that can meet both lifestyle and budgetary requirements.

While white gold is a wonderful choice for diamonds, it has some drawbacks. First, it does not have the old-world richness that is inherent in the appearance of yellow gold. On one hand it actually resembles silver, which is a far cheaper metal. Secondly, white gold contains a mix of metals designed to mask the yellow color of the gold component, but it does not do so fully. White gold alloys are generally “off-white” in color and require rhodium plating to give the metal a bright white luster.

Rhodium plating does give white gold a wonderful look that is particularly beneficial to diamond jewelry, especially with colorless or near-colorless diamonds. The alloys used also give it excellent hardness which reduces the tendency of gold to deform, such as rings going out-of-round due to gripping things in daily life. The rhodium “shell” also gives white gold a bit more scratch resistance.

The Price of Platinum has Changed the Equation
Shoppers preferring the appearance of white gold also usually consider platinum. Until recently platinum has been considered the premium precious metal, and many shoppers have opted for white gold to get the look of platinum at a more budget-friendly price. But boy things have changed! The current spot price of gold has all but eliminated the price premium long associated with platinum.

And from a value standpoint, it’s hard to argue that platinum is not the way to go if you want the look of white metal for your fine jewelry. Used in almost pure form (90-95% pure) the inherent whiteness of platinum needs no rhodium plating and can be polished to a mirror finish. Platinum is extremely durable, though not as hard as white gold alloys. It is considered a “sticky” metal in that it does not flake or wear away.

Fashion, Features and Funds
The decision of which precious metal is right for you and your fine jewelry project centers around three basic things. As mentioned, there has been a resurgence in the popularity of yellow gold in the last few years after decades of dominance by white gold. Fashion trends both follow and lead changes in consumer preferences. It’s sometimes hard to tell which is cause and which is effect, but there is definitely a trend towards yellow gold in the market today.

The particular features or characteristics of the metal also contribute to preference and trend. As a naturally white metal that does not require plating platinum has a leg up over white gold. Platinum is also a more durable metal; highly malleable and capable of being repolished with minimal loss of material. Platinum prongs do not get thin and brittle over time as gold alloys tend to do. And platinum is a denser, heavier material than gold alloys giving it a richer “feel”. Of course, this may be a negative in certain earring styles which may be more comfortable to wear in a lighter weight gold alloy.

And budget considerations always play a big part in decision making. With the high price of gold today and the relatively low price of platinum, the economic difference has been turned on its head. Platinum items may still cost as much or more than the same item in a gold alloy due to the fact that platinum weighs more and is used in almost pure form. But the premium for platinum over gold alloys has been largely erased due to the run-up in the spot price of gold.

What are your preferences in precious metals and what factors influence your decision?
 
I really like the look and heavy feel of platinum for rings for sure. I don't have any earrings in platinum, but I tend to wear studs so the weight difference might not be significant. White metals look better with my skin tone, but my body chemistry tends to eat away at rhodium in a heartbeat. I did have a 14K white gold band that lost it's rhodium in about three weeks, and to be honest the super pale yellow was pretty nice color.

To make a long story short, I prefer platinum for most things, and probably unplated white gold after that.
 
I’ve never liked platinum and have always chosen 18ct white gold regularly rhodium plated.
I also don’t like the colour of high carat yellow gold, my favourite gold is antique 9ct Rose gold, it has a pink colour that appeals to me.
I’m also a fan of green gold.
That said, some gemstones like Rubies have to be set in high carat yellow gold to best display their beauty.
Other gemstones like Aquamarine I feel look better in white metals.
 
I only wear white metals and would probably have everything made in Platinum if I could afford to do so or the piece is practical to be made in PT so that I do not have not worry about re-plating it from time to time.

DK :))
 
Interesting -- thank you! Color of the gem dictates color of the metal for me. Then again, we don't have any diamonds to speak of -- where you could easily go either way.

I love the warmth (slight brownish-ness) of unplated 18K palladium WG, esp in a matte finish. I love platinum, too -- I like the heft for a man's ring. And I love the gray, almost-gunmetal look in a matte finish. It is soft, though.

Plated WG is too chrome-like for me and I tend to associate it -- rightly or wrongly -- with lower-end jewelry. We have some and have never worn off the plating. But I may just be so biased now by all the Edwardian and Deco masterpieces that I drool over and save screenshots of.

I would avoid anything nickel-containing; multiple friends and family members have developed metal allergies from rings.
 
I’m not a fan of platinum - I find it looks a bit grey and I don’t like that on myself! My go-to is usually WG, but I also have some YG. I tend to want to match the metal to my clothes so I like to have options in both colours!
 
I like the warm look of unplated white gold, and I also love yellow gold, 14k or 18K.
I don't have any platinum and don't desire any.
 
i love gold coloured gold
if i want a white metal i just go silver and preferably not rhodium platted
 
I’ve never liked platinum and have always chosen 18ct white gold regularly rhodium plated.
I also don’t like the colour of high carat yellow gold, my favourite gold is antique 9ct Rose gold, it has a pink colour that appeals to me.
I’m also a fan of green gold.
That said, some gemstones like Rubies have to be set in high carat yellow gold to best display their beauty.
Other gemstones like Aquamarine I feel look better in white metals.

could you elaborate on why you go that white gold route? 18ct just to rhodium plate it? Less gold would make it less warm, requiring less frequent rhodium playing. Why pay for something you’re dipping? You like other 9ct metals, as you say-
I would love to understand this thought process a little better. There must be something I am missing.
 
could you elaborate on why you go that white gold route? 18ct just to rhodium plate it? Less gold would make it less warm, requiring less frequent rhodium playing. Why pay for something you’re dipping? You like other 9ct metals, as you say-
I would love to understand this thought process a little better. There must be something I am missing.
I find Platinum too “grey” and I don’t like the patina it develops. The one platinum ring I had when I resized it had a seam where it was made bigger which annoyed me. Whether that was the jeweller or just an outcome I don’t know but it put me off platinum. And I actually love the bright shiny colour of rhodium plating. Just preferences I guess.
As for antique 9ct Rose gold, it is just a lovely colour to my eye.
 
I find Platinum too “grey” and I don’t like the patina it develops. The one platinum ring I had when I resized it had a seam where it was made bigger which annoyed me. Whether that was the jeweller or just an outcome I don’t know but it put me off platinum. And I actually love the bright shiny colour of rhodium plating. Just preferences I guess.
As for antique 9ct Rose gold, it is just a lovely colour to my eye.

I was asking why you’d get 18ct white gold just to rhodium plate it. Why not opt for 9?
 
With gold prices going crazy high and platinum prices relatively stable, I think it’s safe to say 18K yellow/white/rose gold is currently more expensive than 950 platinum in retail, or at least pretty much on par. Is 14K gold cheaper than 950 platinum in retail?
 
I have always preferred platinum...I like the grey and I like the easy maintenance. Not a fan of rhodium plating
 
I have a mix of all three so I tend to accumulate all three types evenly so that I can match metals if I need to.
 
I have white gold in most cases because platinum wasn't available as an option. I choose 14k yellow gold (I prefer this color on my skin) or platinum if I do have an option, depending on the stone.
 
I wear only yg. It brightens my skin tone. White metals make my skin look green ( not like acid actually coloring the skin, just the tone). Also I am allergic to nickel.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top