Would appreciate expert opinions on princess

[thefridge]

I have recently received the following measurements on two princess diamonds. I would appreciate any opinions re dimensions/proportions.
hopefully the info provided is enough.
Thanks very much.

Princess 1.0 carats
Colour:G
Clarity: VS2
L x W 5.53 x 5.44 mm
L:W Ratio: 1.02
Cut: V. Good
Polish: V. Good
Symmetry: V. Good
Total Depth: 70.8% (3.8 mm)
Table Width: 69.3%
Crown Depth: 12.9%
Crown Angle: 40.8 Degr.
Pavilion Depth: 53.5%
Girdle: 3.3%
Culet: None
Fluorescence: None

4,700$ US

Princess 1.0 carats
Colour:G
Clarity: VS2
L x W 5.45 x 5.45 mm
L:W Ratio: 1.00 (Square)
Cut: V. Good
Polish: V. Good
Symmetry: V. Good
Total Depth: 73.1% (3.9 mm)
Table Width: 69.4%
Crown Depth: 12.1%
Crown Angle: 40.3 Degr.
Pavilion Depth: 56.2%
Girdle: 3.5%
Culet: None
Fluorescence: None

5000 US$

 

[fuffi]

hi fridge-

Both look like great candidates. Which one actually looks better to you? If these are online stones, perhaps you could have someone eyeball them for you and give you their opinion? There is no reason to pay for the extra depth in stone 2 on paper but it may be the prettier diamond.

Hope this helps.

 

[thefridge]

Hello Fuffi,

Thanks for your reply.
The stones are online (diamond exchange Canada), but I may have the opportunity to see them in person this weekend when I travel to Toronto.

I'll let you know how things turn out.

Cheers,

The Fridge