Natural Diamond Prices – January 2025
PriceScope has been tracking and reporting monthly insights into the online retail diamond market for nearly two decades. Our analysis offers unique value to consumers and stakeholders within the diamond…
When choosing an engagement ring, the metal you select is just as important as the diamond or gemstone it holds. Among the many choices available, white gold and silver are two timeless and elegant options that often draw comparisons due to their similar appearance. However, each metal comes with its own set of characteristics, advantages, and drawbacks. To help you make an informed decision, we’ve created this comprehensive guide comparing white gold and silver for engagement rings.
Find a Diamond for Your White Gold or Silver Engagement Ring. Explore PriceScope’s Premium Diamond Search Tool to compare prices from top vendors like Whiteflash, Blue Nile, James Allen, B2C Jewels, and Adiamor in real time.
What is White Gold Made Of?
14K white gold is an alloy created by mixing pure gold (58.5% or 14 divided by 24) with other metals, such as copper (22%), zinc (8%), nickel (7%), or silver (4.5%), to give it a silvery-white appearance. To enhance its whiteness, white gold is typically plated with rhodium, which also provides a brilliant, mirror-like finish. Commonly available in 10K, 14K, and 18K, white gold is celebrated for its luxurious appeal and suitability for fine jewelry, including engagement rings.
However, some people are allergic to the nickel used in white gold in the USA and Canada. European countries and many others have banned nickel in white gold because 15% to 20% of the population have nickel allergies. Nickel-free white gold alloys replace nickel with palladium, which is much more expensive, along with silver, copper, zinc, and other metals from the palladium group.
Pros and Cons of White Gold
Pros:
- Durability: White gold is stronger and more resistant to scratches than silver, making it ideal for everyday wear.
- Luster: The rhodium plating adds a high level of shine and sophistication.
- Low Tarnish Risk: Unlike silver, white gold doesn’t tarnish, although the rhodium wears off over time.
Cons:
- Allergic Reactions: Some white gold alloys contain nickel, which can cause skin irritation for sensitive individuals.
- Maintenance: To maintain the metal’s shiny white brightness, rhodium plating needs periodic reapplication.
- Price: An ounce of gold costs more than 80 times an ounce of silver, making 18K and 14K white gold jewelry significantly more expensive than silver jewelry.
Engagement Ring Insurance. Ensure peace of mind with Jewelers Mutual Jewelry Insurance. Safeguard your diamond engagement ring against loss, theft, and damage with trusted coverage. Get Insured Today
What is Silver Made Of?
Silver, one of the oldest precious metals used in jewelry, has a naturally bright, reflective finish. The most common type used in jewelry is sterling silver, an alloy made up of 92.5% silver and 7.5% other metals, such as copper, to enhance its hardness. While sterling silver is affordable and hypoallergenic, making it a popular choice for various jewelry styles, it is too soft and prone to bending for use in engagement rings.
Pros and Cons of Silver
Pros:
- Affordability: Silver is budget-friendly, making it an excellent option for those seeking a beautiful yet economical choice.
- Hypoallergenic: Sterling silver is typically safe for sensitive skin.
- Timeless Look: Its natural luster and versatility complement many jewelry designs.
Cons:
- Tarnishing: Silver tarnishes over time, requiring frequent cleaning and polishing to maintain its shine.
- Softness: Silver is more prone to bending, scratches, and dents than white gold. However, it is actually harder than gold alloys, which means silver rings should not be worn alongside gold rings, as they can cause wear on the gold.
- Perceived Value: Silver is often viewed as less luxurious than white gold.
Shop Whiteflash A CUT ABOVE® Diamonds. Whiteflash's premium range of A CUT ABOVE® diamonds, is known for their exceptional precision and light performance. Perfect for pairing with an engagement ring setting of choice.
How to Tell the Difference Between White Gold and Silver
Aspect | White Gold | Silver |
Color and Shine | Bright white hue with a polished, mirrored finish due to rhodium plating. | Silver has a brighter, whiter appearance, though it can tarnish over time. |
Markings | Stamped with its karatage (e.g., “14K” or “18K”). | Stamped with purity marks like “925” (indicating sterling silver). |
Tarnish | Doesn’t tarnish, though the rhodium layer may dull and need reapplication. | Silver tarnishes over time, often causing the area beneath diamonds to darken, which can make the stones appear dull. |
Price | Significantly more expensive, reflecting its gold content and durability. | More affordable, making it a budget-friendly choice. |
Which is Better for Engagement Rings: White Gold or Silver?
Shop James Allen’s TRUE HEARTS™ Collection. Examine diamonds up close with James Allen’s TRUE HEARTS™ diamonds, featuring premium-cut diamonds for your engagement ring. Enjoy 360-degree HD views of every loose diamond.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between white gold and silver for an engagement ring comes down to personal preference, budget, and lifestyle. White gold offers a more luxurious and durable option, ideal for those seeking a high-end look and low-maintenance wear. On the other hand, silver is perfect for those who prioritize affordability and appreciate its timeless charm.
Both metals are excellent choices for engagement rings, but the right one for you depends on what matters most in your decision-making process. Whether you opt for white gold or silver, you’ll be investing in a stunning and meaningful piece of jewelry that lasts a lifetime.
