Advice/comments on my CAD renderings

[TSEliot]

I am having a local jeweler make a platinum setting with tapered baguettes. I want a simple, classic, petite ring. I have a 2ct emerald cut diamond as the center stone. I used the Kwiat tapered baguette setting as the inspiration. I also like the tapered baguette ring from Tiffany.

http://www.kwiat.com/fine-diamond-jewelry/emerald-cut-diamond-platinum-ring-tapered-baguettes/p/58093/98/0/0
http://www.tiffany.com/engagement/item.aspx?groupsku=grp10034

Please let me know your opinions on these renderings. Does it look too industrial? Is there something off about the view from the top? I really appreciate your feedback. I want to get this right!

 

[chrono]

Personal preference. My preference is to have the setting more tapered so I see more diamonds and less metal, or at least longer baguettes.

 

[Enerchi]

Both the kwait and the Tiffany are more tapered than the CAD one shown. They taper from the end of the baguette and they also have a "notch" or "airspace" triangular wedge that the CAD is missing, where the baguette ends and the taper meets the shank. The CAD seems 'industrial' as you say - it does appear heavier than the shanks of the originals you are linking to.

I'd ask for a revision and make the setting much finer and delicate than shown.

 

[SB621]

Besides the tapering, I would also have them fix the prongs. If possible have them do claw prongs (in Tiffany's inspriation) instead of the pegs they have in the CAD.

Overall lovely ring. I'm a big fan of this classis setting and used to have something similar with an asscher CS for a RHR.