Advice required on Color and Cut

[alcat]

Hi,

I need some advice on a diamond I intend purchasing and narrowed my search down to 2 stones (brilliant round shape). Both stones are GIA certified. I'm not sure which of the following 2 will be the best option:

Option1:
color F, 1.3 carat, Ideal cut, VS1
Excellent Polish and symmetry
L/W ratio - 1.00, Depth - 61.5%
Table % - 58%, Fluor - Strong Blue
Measure - 6.99x7.02x4.31mm
Girdle - Medium, Cutlet - none

Option2:
color E, 1.27 carat, Very Good cut, VVS2
Very good Polish and Good symmetry
L/W ratio - 1.01, Depth - 62.6%
Table % - 56%, Fluor - Faint
Measure - 6.84x6.92x4.31mm
Girdle - Medium, Cutlet - small

Any advice will be greatly appreciated.

Thank you

 

[BrianJohnson]

Both are very close.

I'd go with Option 2, the strong fluorescence of Option 1 concerns me.
Also the E color grade will probably price better. Looks like you're going for a high quality rock.
Good luck.

Can you take a look at my other posting on this forum?
I'd love your thoughts.