Hi I’ve become sensitive to all non hypoallergenic makeup now as well when I turn d 40. Especially the eye makeup. Two drug store brands that I buy that are affordable are E.L.F. Who have a great eyebrow pencil and tinted gel and eyeliner pencil. Also Almaty. I bought their mascara , eyeliner, eyeshadow, and eye primer and LOVE! Of course is Physicians Formula as well. I use their CC cream, concealer and bronzer. And setting powder. On a splurge at At Sephora I love Tarte , Tower28, and some others I can’t think of now. I can’t even wear earrings anymore unless they are hypoallergenic backings. So annoying!