shape
carat
color
clarity

Asscher Evaluation- need help

Alcestis

Rough_Rock
Joined
Oct 27, 2024
Messages
13
(I've moved this post here after posting in the wrong spot originally - apologies!)

Hi all! I'm desperate for help evaluating if the "short list" I've made is any good or if I need to go back to the drawing board. I've done a ton of reading browsing and what I've come to find is that it is truly difficult to observe good light performance online, even given ideal specs- but given my budget I am set out to give it my best

What I am looking for:
Lab grown asscher, 3-4 carats (give or take). D-H, VVS2 or higher, small table, symmetric steps, wider windmills and good scintillation and flash.

One thing that has me confused is some sources say "watch out for black/darkness in the image" others say you need the high contrast and that GREY is actually what can show light leakage under the table... Maybe someone can set me straight here.

Thank you for reading this far and here are the three currently on my short list. My untrained eye has me leaving toward the first two more but I'm here for your opinions and observations! Anything helps!

Option 1 video
Option 1 certificate

UPDATE: I have not been able to locate more images of this online but have sent a message to the seller requesting additional photos/videos and will upload them if they are able to send them to me.


UPDATE; OPTION 2 AND 3 HAVE BEEN DELETED after some of you here vetoed them! Thank you! I'll be on the hunt for further options to contend with option 1

Here is a photo of what I plan to do with it (of the two rings shown on hand I am drawn to the larger one but would choose a smaller stone if it looked nicer)

Thank you so much for any guidance!!
 
I find that with fancy cuts even the best 360 videos and ASET images only give best guesses. It’s hard to say with certainty whether it’s a good fancy cut without seeing it in person or with more videos in different lighting. Unless you have a trusted jeweler who can vet stones for you, I think it’s really important to see it loose in person before committing to a setting.
 
Thank you- I think you're right. I am ope to potentially buying two reasonable options and sending back the one that doesn't preform as well.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP

Featured Topics

Top