Borsheims

[clarity1264]

What are peoples thoughts on this website for women’s engagement rings?

 

[kenny]

You can't even pick your individual diamond.
You're just stick with whatever diamond they put into the setting.
I didn't see gemological grading reports on the few pieces I browsed, even for what they call a yellow diamond.
If it isn't stated, I'm sure the diamond cut is not ideal.

Therefore I would not shop there.

I care very much that the diamond I buy has ideal cut.
Only then can it deliver the best light show.
High Color and Clarity grades do not produce a better light show.
Only the best cut does that.

I'd buy an ACA diamond from Whitefish, superb cut, great prices, great service, and great policies.
Since it's best to buy the diamond and setting at the same vendor I'd pick the setting I like best from WF's website.

 

[peppermintpatty]

I love Borsheims and have shopped there for over 2 decades. They do let you buy an individual diamond and they are GIA graded. You can see the certificate number on the listing for each diamond. They have a huge inventory online. Keep in mind that all of those diamonds are not in store. They get them in. I try to narrow it down to 2 -4 and they bring them in. I am fortunate that I am close enough to travel and see them in person. I do not believe they could offer you and ASET. That might be a deal breaker for you...

You then can decide if you want to purchase the setting itself there or elsewhere. I think their prices are competitive and their customer service is excellent based on my experiences. They do have a variety of designer settings as well as Borsheims settings.

They also have an excellent upgrade policy. It's not double the price. No certain amount you have to spend to upgrade.

I have worked with only 2 people and they both were excellent.

If you want an ACA, then Whiteflash is the way to go for sure! If you want to be able to look at the GIA cert and determine from that you like the cut, then Borsheims is a solid choice. I realize you don't want to buy a cert but rather the diamond. Like I said I go look at the diamonds in person. As always cut is king! Many people are happy with a well cut diamond.
Some are not and an ideal cut like ACA is what works best for them.

It's all about what works best for you and your budget.

I'm not sure if I can give the person's name that I work with here on Pricescope. If I can I will be happy to

Good luck with your search!