debating between 2 cushions

[righthandring]

Hello everyone. I am debating between 2 cushion brilliants with the same type of cert. One is better in color and the other in clarity. They are the same in symmetry and polish. In weighing all the factors, as between the following factors, which do you think is the better stone? Or are the characteristics below not a big enough deal to consider in the debate when there is a big cost difference? I have not seen them in person. Thanks for any help.

Stone 1: Table 61%; Depth 68.4%; slightly thick/thick

Stone 2: Table 55%; Depth 65.8; slightly thick/very thick

 

[diamondseeker2006]

None of us can advise you with that limited amount of information. Numbers can look fine and the stone can look awful.

Look at this thread and you'll see 3 cushions that are very different. These are some of the better ones, but 2 of the three I personally would not buy. You'll see how they can be different. He posted earlier threads with some bad ones. So it is just impossible to buy a cushion without the magnified photo and ASET image.

[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/down-to-3-please-pick-one.185963/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/down-to-3-please-pick-one.185963/[/URL]