Diamond studs for a man - what size is too big and what color is too low?

[fire&ice]

Don't know how well cut those diamonds you looked at were (i.e. there mm) - but you may want to consider stones just shy of .5 like .43 or so. The price break is quite a bit & the size diff not quite so.

 

[hoorray]

Agreed,

If you focus on the diameter mm and cut, you can easily stay below the .5 ctw (each) and get the good sized price break without sacrificing diameter or looks of 1ctw. Also, f-g color is good, but I can only see the color of my new G stones when I put them up against something icier, not on their own. My new white gold setting have a yellowish tinge (the first time I have had this, but i guess it depends on the mix), so watch out for that.

 

[jenibear]

Thanks for the help guys.

I plan to talk to a vendor I've worked with in the past Monday and see where it goes.
There are several pairs I've found on here that look good, but I want to check with this vendor first.

I like the icy look, as does my FI, so I'm hoping to find the perfect stone in a F. If that means going to a .45 each, that's OK.

I'll keep you posted. I can't wait!

Jenibear

 

[pqcollectibles]

Dittos to F&I and Lop, JB. When I was looking locally, I checked on the diameter measurements as well. The 1 ctw studs in the local shops had nearly the same diameter as Ideal cuts just below the .5 carat mark. I got .87 ctw Ideal cut studs that have the look of jewelry store 1 ctw. Mine perform much better and they cost less than generic studs I found locally.

 

[jenibear]

So how do these sound?
I expect to get the lab reports Tuesday.
They are both ideal cut and H&A with AGS reports.
One is a .42 ct. VS2 H for $925 and the second is .43 ct. VS2 H for $940.
Good deal?
And will there be a noticable difference between a store .50 and an ideal .43?
I'd rather get a G SI1 (and am asking the vendor if they can get for me) - but is there really a difference?
Thanks!

Jenibear

 

[hoorray]

good point britchick! I just bought SI2's for my studs, and they are absolutly fine, and were a better value.

 

[fire&ice]

Yeah, for a match pair the mm measurements are very important.

 

[jenibear]

Here goes the AGS report and again the price I got was $940.

 

[jenibear]

Here's the bscope

 

[jenibear]

Here's teh second one. Price quote: $925

 

[jenibear]

Here's the bscope.

 

[jenibear]

BUMP!

I need some feedback!

 

[jenibear]

Where IS everyone?

Please let me know if these are a good pick!

 

[pqcollectibles]

They look like a good match, JB. He will adore you so for this wonderful gift!!

 

[jenibear]

Thanks PQ,
but I passed on these in favor of a pair of ideal H&A F SI1s from the same vendor.
They are also larger - .90 tcw and close to 5 mm.

I expect the AGS certs, etc. Thursday. I am hoping these are the ones!

Jenibear

 

[pqcollectibles]

Kewl, JB. I think both you and your FI will be pleased with the result.

1 ctw generic studs I was looking at ran around 5 mm each in diameter. If you had the stones side by side, you might see the size difference. Standing alone, all anyone will see is the glitz and sparkle of you beau's new perties.

 

[hoorray]

Hey Jenibear -- congratulations on finding the stones! They sound like just the right combinations for you with the F color 1cttw. 5mm should be a great size.

 

[Mara]

Sounds good JB... F SI is a very nice combo. Do post the data.

 

[jenibear]

Thanks guys.

I'll post the info as soon as I get it.
These stones sound just like the ones I was hoping for. I am sure the .10 ct won't be very noticable in size, especially if they sparkle like mad!

Jenibear

 

[goldyhoops]

I think it wonderful you are buying diamond earrings for your man, he's very lucky to have you.

I've never had a girlfriend give me earrings.

I'm a man and have had both of my ears pierced for about 14 years. I mainly wear small gold hoops but since reading all this deeply helpful advice I might get a pair of diamond earrings myself.

But I'll think I'll postpone the chandelier earrings.

 

[wallace]

Hi - What a great idea! Can't wait to see the pictures!
It sounds like you are all set but one thing I think is funny that no one brought up - is what size (height/wt) is your FI?

Just for anyone reading this post later, maybe his overall size would help determine what carat you want. For example, if he were a petit man the .50 or larger might not acheive the desired look. As Aubrey put it, your sailor/hipster would start looking like a rap star! If your guy is a huge burly rugby-type and very tall, He could go higher up the carat chart without looking like a blingster. We talk about women with tiny and large fingers/hands and sizes that work best for those shapes - I just thought it might help here.

Of course, there's always the size four who can pull off a monster rock and vice versa - but then a look is being acheived.

Congratulations - on your engagement and on getting a guy you can get fun presents for!

 

[jenibear]

Goldyhoops - I'm glad my guy isn't the only one. He got his ears pierced when he was 14 playing soccer in Europe for the summer.

And Warren, my man is only 5 feet 8 1/2 inches tall (I'm a half inch taller!

) - but he's stocky, muscular and has a big presence!

When we went to the store and I put 1/2 carat studs on his earlobe they looked perfect.

There's just something about him that can pull it off. I can't put my finger on it.

And as I said, he's got big ears!

He also has distinguished features and large eyes and a huge smile. So I think all that offsets his short stature. He often has more presence in a room than some of his friends that are over 6 feet tall!

I'm trying to post the info, but am having a hard time.

Let's hope it works today!

Jenibear

 

[jenibear]

Here is the AGS report on the first stone.

 

[jenibear]

Let's try that again right side up!

 

[jenibear]

Great light return!

 

[jenibear]

Stone number two. These are exactly the same size! How crazy! They are like twins! You can barely tell them apart!

 

[jenibear]

More great light return!

 

[hoorray]

Wow -- these look like a great match and a great selection for earrings! Congratulations on a great find!

 

[jenibear]

Yay!
I am in love with these!
Can't wait to see them in real life!

 

[jenibear]

Here is a photo of the actual stones! Yummy!