shape
carat
color
clarity

Do You Still Have Your Original Engagement Ring

  • Thread starter Thread starter MTHealthyLiving
  • Start date Start date
My first engagement ring was a 1/4 ct solitaire in a swoopy white gold head on a yellow band. The diamond was given to us by my father, as it was my deceased mother's diamond and we were both full time college students and my then-fiance was only 19 at the time.

We put it in a setting, and it was the thinnest, lightest setting imaginable and it was great for someone of that age at that time (1982)...but was not the ring to carry one through life. My wedding ring was a tiny band of 8 1 pt stones set in white gold on a yellow gold band. As it turned out, the white gold had nickel in it and I was allergic to it, so didn't wear it much or for long. My husband wore his ring consistently till it snapped while helping some friends move house. We took that opportunity to melt down the yellow gold in my wedding band, my engagement ring, and his wedding ring (6mm wide and fairly heavy), and make 2 new rings for our 25th wedding anniversary. DH'S ring is 2.5mm wide and mine is 2mm, and both are nice and thick, half round comfort fit with milgrain. Our original rings were only 9 kt gold, so we added enough pure gold to the remakes to bump them up to 14 kt. This gave us enough gold left over to make me 2 small pendants - a solid disk with our initials and wedding date engraved on it and the 8 diamonds from my wedding band set around it, and a smaller disc with the first diamond my husband ever bought me with his own money bezel set in the middle. I wear the 2 pendants together on the one chain, and call it my wedding pendant. That pendant and my remade wedding ring are the two pieces my husband would never resell if anything ever happened to me, and they're on my '5 things you'd save in the event of a fire' list.

The diamond from my original e-ring later went on to be one diamond in a pair of earrings I had made for my niece, who never met her grand mother, and whom I wanted to have something from my mother, who would have loved her very much.

DKJPV_0514_STEAR-1.jpg

20181225_115337.jpg
 
Last edited:
D5B26678-AEC1-4168-A527-6FAA8EBCA1A4.jpeg Yes, I still have. It is plain, 4mm YG band. And I wear it often
 
I have the setting. I never liked it and had it reset before the wedding. My husband had a local jeweler make it based on a pic I sent him of a style I liked. The final product scared me and reminded me of talons.
7A75892F-57E3-4707-9E51-823C33BCA1D9.jpeg 510D0854-1F3A-4E5C-A49F-3F9C15CD9043.jpeg 2EB6E44B-BD6F-440E-9011-200DF03C93E7.jpeg

Trabert Goldsmiths made the second setting and the whole experience was terrible. I would heartily recommend them to people I dislike. They had it made in Thailand and the quality was so bad that the shank warped when I picked up a carry on bag.
POS.jpg

The last reset was done by Kataoka. I went to their shop in Tokyo, showed the designer a ring of his that I liked, and he sketched out some ideas. I didn’t even see the wax model before it was cast and it still came out exactly how I wanted it. The whole experience couldn’t have been easier and I have no plans of resetting it again. The stone is a branded cut and I had reservations about it. Once I saw it in this setting, I finally loved it.
C4D4EA5C-753B-4EDA-9945-F424ED79E379.jpeg

JPie, Your ring is gorgeous!!!!
 
NOPE, and I sometimes wish I still did for sentimentality reasons.
I started out with a 1cttw three stone from Zales in white and yellow gold. It was a gorgeous setting but horrible quality, I1 poorly cut diamonds, and stones were constantly falling out of the setting.

My second wedding set I had custom made, and I absolutely adore it. GIA VS2 OEC in a beautiful floral rose gold setting. I sold my original set to help fund the second set.

I'm on my 3rd wedding set now, only because I lost two ring sizes after having my third baby and my second wedding set isn't easily sizeable. I briefly listed my second set thinking I'd use the funds to help upgrade to a bigger center diamond. But luckily no one bought it, and I found my new current set preloved for a fantastic price; and it just happened to be my style entirely. So I'm now wearing my second set as a RHR and getting use to my third set.

I most likely won't be getting a bigger upgrade until all of my children are out of the house. So I'm pretty sure I'm keeping what I have for at least a couple decades. But someday my dream over 1ct AVC will be mine!!!Rissring23.jpg dsc03768.jpg IMG_20180701_130904.jpg ;-)

I love it! So unique!!!

I sold my original wedding ring set.
The E-ring was three stones in the middle with many stones all over front, back and sides, wedding band was simple 5 stones.

Don’t have close up picture of it, just these =)2
2CE6E4A2-45C4-4208-8AA9-AFBD22C25289.jpeg A8BC55EE-BC99-477D-89FE-443DA0DE0465.jpeg

Beautiful!

I have my original e-ring but haven't worn it in years. The setting was nothing but trouble. Prongs broke, bands rubbed, etc. We were young & my soon-to-be husband worked really hard to surprise me with it in a time when we could hardly swing groceries. A lot of friends got married/engaged later than we did & have some stunners with serious coverage (hello DSS). But I'm still very sentimental about the diamond, I won't ever upgrade it. 10 years and 3 babies later I'm in the process of having it set into a CVB. I've still got the original setting with hopes I can re-purpose the little stones one day.

original
CVB cad unnamed.jpg
I love the before and the after!! Love the pairing with the rose gold band!

gosh alright, it's just a 0.5ct equivalent moissy center but if you insist! ;)2 It has certainly brought me much joy over the years, and husband is also quite proud (in fact he endearingly calls all my other rings "traitor rings").

KPr3nRE.png

tEVl5lE.png


I took these just for you; please excuse my nails, I went swimming a day ago and some polish just peeled right off! :oops2:

@Babyblue033 do you have more pics of your original? The center looks BLUE, surrounded by pink; I love all the color going on! Your new OEC is also spectacular!
@poshmommy holy crap that's beautiful

I love that: “traitor rings” LOL

I think the shape of that stone suits the ring (and your hand) perfectly!

My first engagement ring was a 1/4 ct solitaire in a swoopy white gold head on a yellow band. The diamond was given to us by my father, as it was my deceased mother's diamond and we were both full time college students and my then-fiance was only 19 at the time.

We put it in a setting, and it was the thinnest, lightest setting imaginable and it was great for someone of that age at that time (1982)...but was not the ring to carry one through life. My wedding ring was a tiny band of 8 1 pt stones set in white gold on a yellow gold band. As it turned out, the white gold had nickel in it and I was allergic to it, so didn't wear it much or for long. My husband wore his ring consistently till it snapped while helping some friends move house. We took that opportunity to melt down the yellow gold in my wedding band, my engagement ring, and his wedding ring (6mm wide and fairly heavy), and make 2 new rings for our 25th wedding anniversary. DH'S ring is 2.5mm wide and mine is 2mm, and both are nice and thick, half round comfort fit with milgrain. Our original rings were only 9 kt gold, so we added enough pure gold to the remakes to bump them up to 14 kt. This gave us enough gold left over to make me 2 small pendants - a solid disk with our initials and wedding date engraved on it and the 8 diamonds from my wedding band set around it, and a smaller disc with the first diamond my husband ever bought me with his own money bezel set in the middle. I wear the 2 pendants together on the one chain, and call it my wedding pendant. That pendant and my remade wedding ring are the two pieces my husband would never resell if anything ever happened to me, and they're on my '5 things you'd save in the event of a fire' list.

The diamond from my original e-ring later went on to be one diamond in a pair of earrings I had made for my niece, who never met her grand mother, and whom I wanted to have something from my mother, who would have loved her very much.

DKJPV_0514_STEAR-1.jpg

20181225_115337.jpg

Gorgeous!!! Love the meaning behind these pieces and the execution!
 
At the time I had my ring made, Kataoka had one store in Tokyo, and they only accepted custom orders after an in-person consultation. I took advantage of a family wedding in Hong Kong to visit Japan and left my diamond in its old setting. The next time I saw my diamond was when it arrived in its new setting. We had agreed to shipping terms during the consultation so I got it delivery duty paid and didn’t have to deal with customs.

I’m not sure how it works with shipping now that they have a store in New York.

Did you have a project in mind? Hope you don’t mind my asking - excited at the prospect of seeing new shiny things!

Thank you so much for the information! Bookmarking for a faraway future project — wish I had known that they set outside stones. I’ve always loved Kataoka but wasn’t really interested in the diamonds that they source. I love how they use five prongs on round diamonds, and their aesthetic is so dreamy and delicate :love:
 
Yes!!!! 0.5ct of dubious origins! At least it wasn't a mall ring though! The cutting would make PSers scream and cower in horror but the colour looks decent!

Hubs bought it for me using all of his scholarship prize money and it was the start of all the lovely things we've bought together in this life.

I have a lot of fond memories of the adorable 19 year old boy who bought 19 year old drama queen me the ring. Now we're a lot older, a lot less dramatic and more sensible jewellery shoppers but I still like to wear the ring and reminisce our crazy youth.
 
I do have my original ering and wedding band but it now contains a spinel. The original diamonds (.15 ct and 2 .03 ct) are now in an open heart pendant.
 
Yes I do. I got engaged in 2001 and my husband bought a .7 ct, F, vs1 HOF diamond from a mall near my university. I have no plans to upgrade the diamond but do need to resize the ring and perhaps reset it in a thinner band.
20181228_164304.jpg
20181228_165927.jpg
 
Oh gosh, sorry! Thought I resized it but all I did was saved it in a lower resolution.
 
I love this thread with everyone's stories!

I still have my 1.01ct EC engagement ring and the custom bands; due to allergic reactions and weight fluctuations, I didn't wear them a lot over the past 10 years but recently had them resized so I can enjoy them. DH went crazy trying to find an eye clean EC in our price range and he's VERY picky about what eye clean is to him; he was upset at the quality of the stones Shane Co showed us (he could see the flaws and carbon spots without a loupe). If I was to do it all over again, I probably would do it differently and go with an antique ring, but at the time, I wanted a new diamond; I didn't want to risk wearing a ring from a broken marriage and my husband was adamant that it would be an emerald cut because you can't hide a flaw easily in one and he just loves the simplicity of a step cut.

Now I have a 10 year "upgrade" with a gray pear diamond in an engraved halo with a matching engraved band by CvB. Again, thinking about it, I still might have done things differently if I'd been more active here this past summer and maybe reset my original diamond or remade my set with CvB or DK (especially since it cost $400 just to resize my original ring). But diamond in my new set is as perfectly imperfect as we are, the vines represent our growth, and the different colored metals represent us coming together and it was within our budget after having a rough year.

I have no idea what my husband thinks of a redesign on my original ring, I had a very limited selection when we bought the diamond online out of Georgia and the bands were just made to fit, the setting was pretty but after 10 years of marriage I still can't figure out if it is or is not "me."

20181018_142647.jpg Image-148.jpg
 
img_6990.jpg
This was my mom's setting. She was engaged in 1989 and upgraded to a larger princess cut in 2003, but she kept the setting.

I took the diamond and reset it into my engagement ring in 2016, and I still wear it. I don't plan to upgrade it, but I would probably get more stacking rings/right hand rings.

o4Uqj4F (1).jpgqwbs5231.jpg
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top