onedrop
Ideal_Rock
- Joined
- Aug 24, 2006
- Messages
- 2,216
TravelingGal|1339204811|3212224 said:btw Demelza, I see that your solitaire is still in the 23rd street setting (I came across your thread when I was researching 23rd street for my own project). Has it kept you happy and has it held up well? You are one of the few PSers who used them. I figure it's a good thing that it's still in there because I do remember how many times you dealt with resetting it (good and bad experiences both.) I always thought you did great with choosing the resetting of your gorgeous stone (which I am sure you will not have a problem with reselling should you decide to only keep one.)
Also, please start your own thread with that beauty!
MissGotRocks|1339207148|3212260 said:Hey Dem - always a pleasure to lend an ear and always a delight to see these gorgeous pictures! This new stone is just spectacular but so is your other solitaire. You're blessed with two beautiful stones.
Dreamer_D|1339210150|3212290 said:TravelingGal|1339204811|3212224 said:btw Demelza, I see that your solitaire is still in the 23rd street setting (I came across your thread when I was researching 23rd street for my own project). Has it kept you happy and has it held up well? You are one of the few PSers who used them. I figure it's a good thing that it's still in there because I do remember how many times you dealt with resetting it (good and bad experiences both.) I always thought you did great with choosing the resetting of your gorgeous stone (which I am sure you will not have a problem with reselling should you decide to only keep one.)
Also, please start your own thread with that beauty!
Dem can answer for herself, but I thought I would add that I did not know who made her mount and complimented its beauty and function! It is very comfortable to wear and the prongs are divine. It looks like a well made piece too in proportion, dainty but sturdy too.
TravelingGal|1339213932|3212331 said:Dreamer_D|1339210150|3212290 said:TravelingGal|1339204811|3212224 said:btw Demelza, I see that your solitaire is still in the 23rd street setting (I came across your thread when I was researching 23rd street for my own project). Has it kept you happy and has it held up well? You are one of the few PSers who used them. I figure it's a good thing that it's still in there because I do remember how many times you dealt with resetting it (good and bad experiences both.) I always thought you did great with choosing the resetting of your gorgeous stone (which I am sure you will not have a problem with reselling should you decide to only keep one.)
Also, please start your own thread with that beauty!
Dem can answer for herself, but I thought I would add that I did not know who made her mount and complimented its beauty and function! It is very comfortable to wear and the prongs are divine. It looks like a well made piece too in proportion, dainty but sturdy too.
Cool thanks! I remember seeing it thinking, that looks as good as a Leon! Then when I went to research, I found the thread again and reread Demelza's journey and it swayed me to think 23rd street was going to be OK since she had some other good settings that didn't work out and this one seemed to hit the mark.
The one that threw me was the locke. I remember it being one of the more beautiful settings at the time (another PSer had one that I thought was amazing...she was an interesting study, actually) but Demelza's looked to be subpar. That nixed Locke for me for the future.
Demelza|1339215530|3212344 said:TravelingGal|1339213932|3212331 said:Dreamer_D|1339210150|3212290 said:TravelingGal|1339204811|3212224 said:btw Demelza, I see that your solitaire is still in the 23rd street setting (I came across your thread when I was researching 23rd street for my own project). Has it kept you happy and has it held up well? You are one of the few PSers who used them. I figure it's a good thing that it's still in there because I do remember how many times you dealt with resetting it (good and bad experiences both.) I always thought you did great with choosing the resetting of your gorgeous stone (which I am sure you will not have a problem with reselling should you decide to only keep one.)
Also, please start your own thread with that beauty!
Dem can answer for herself, but I thought I would add that I did not know who made her mount and complimented its beauty and function! It is very comfortable to wear and the prongs are divine. It looks like a well made piece too in proportion, dainty but sturdy too.
Cool thanks! I remember seeing it thinking, that looks as good as a Leon! Then when I went to research, I found the thread again and reread Demelza's journey and it swayed me to think 23rd street was going to be OK since she had some other good settings that didn't work out and this one seemed to hit the mark.
The one that threw me was the locke. I remember it being one of the more beautiful settings at the time (another PSer had one that I thought was amazing...she was an interesting study, actually) but Demelza's looked to be subpar. That nixed Locke for me for the future.
Hi TGal --
Yes, I'm very pleased with the quality of the workmanship on my ring and it's held up very well since I got it in 2008. As you are well aware, I went through quite a lot trying to set my stone -- some of that was me being neurotic and some of it was sub-par workmanship. My ring from 23rd Street is undoubtedly very well-made and I've had several other jewelers confirm that. I think you'll be very happy with how your beautiful 3-stone wears over the years. One question for you: Was your ring handforged? I ask because I remember seeing a CAD in your thread and I didn't think they did any casting.
Re: Lockes -- that was all just too bizarre. Shortly after my fiasco with them, they closed up shop. I, too, was very surprised by the lack of quality workmanship given that the other PSer you're referring to had a beautiful ring made by them just months before. Rich Sherwood was scratching his head too since he was the one who had appraised both it and mine.
As for the OEC, it came in the setting. It's okay -- not what I would choose as it's a bit too high -- but fine for now. I would like to find another authentic antique setting one of these days, but that will have to wait for now.
TravelingGal|1339216075|3212350 said:Demelza|1339215530|3212344 said:TravelingGal|1339213932|3212331 said:Dreamer_D|1339210150|3212290 said:TravelingGal|1339204811|3212224 said:btw Demelza, I see that your solitaire is still in the 23rd street setting (I came across your thread when I was researching 23rd street for my own project). Has it kept you happy and has it held up well? You are one of the few PSers who used them. I figure it's a good thing that it's still in there because I do remember how many times you dealt with resetting it (good and bad experiences both.) I always thought you did great with choosing the resetting of your gorgeous stone (which I am sure you will not have a problem with reselling should you decide to only keep one.)
Also, please start your own thread with that beauty!
Dem can answer for herself, but I thought I would add that I did not know who made her mount and complimented its beauty and function! It is very comfortable to wear and the prongs are divine. It looks like a well made piece too in proportion, dainty but sturdy too.
Cool thanks! I remember seeing it thinking, that looks as good as a Leon! Then when I went to research, I found the thread again and reread Demelza's journey and it swayed me to think 23rd street was going to be OK since she had some other good settings that didn't work out and this one seemed to hit the mark.
The one that threw me was the locke. I remember it being one of the more beautiful settings at the time (another PSer had one that I thought was amazing...she was an interesting study, actually) but Demelza's looked to be subpar. That nixed Locke for me for the future.
Hi TGal --
Yes, I'm very pleased with the quality of the workmanship on my ring and it's held up very well since I got it in 2008. As you are well aware, I went through quite a lot trying to set my stone -- some of that was me being neurotic and some of it was sub-par workmanship. My ring from 23rd Street is undoubtedly very well-made and I've had several other jewelers confirm that. I think you'll be very happy with how your beautiful 3-stone wears over the years. One question for you: Was your ring handforged? I ask because I remember seeing a CAD in your thread and I didn't think they did any casting.
Re: Lockes -- that was all just too bizarre. Shortly after my fiasco with them, they closed up shop. I, too, was very surprised by the lack of quality workmanship given that the other PSer you're referring to had a beautiful ring made by them just months before. Rich Sherwood was scratching his head too since he was the one who had appraised both it and mine.
As for the OEC, it came in the setting. It's okay -- not what I would choose as it's a bit too high -- but fine for now. I would like to find another authentic antique setting one of these days, but that will have to wait for now.
Gosh Demelza, I LOVE your setting for that OEC. I thought you had it made just for your gorgeous rock!
Thanks for the info on 23rd, and I am glad to hear it's held up well! Yes, it's hand forged. Not sure what 23rd street was like when you had your ring made, but the process was somewhat...er, nebulous, I think for a lot of people. They started doing cads so people could get an "idea." Joni said it made the process a lot less stressful for a lot of people, once they explained what the purpose of the CAD was for. For my ring, it was to show me the mathematical proportions of the flow for my stone size, ring size, etc. As you can see, that's ALL the CAD was good for, as there were some elements that were a surprise to me. Still, all I needed to know was proportions, as that was the most important thing for me.
I heard that they did cast some things? But yeah, Joni said my ring would be all handforged, and when you look at it, the "imperfections" (meaning symmetry in some places) show it was hand forged . I love it.
I had no idea that Lockes closed up shop! I just loved that other PSers ring (I can't remember when in her process it was done, but she was very picky and seemed to love it.) Yours was astounding (not in a good way)...I couldn't believe it was from the same place.
Mara|1339386833|3213525 said:TG...I think you are remembering Matatora who had a Locke setting.
Dem... love those new sunlight pics. That stone is just ridiculously beautiful, so crisp and clear. And I do like that setting.
Demelza|1339223775|3212375 said:Nope, the ring came in that setting. I assume it's original? I'm glad you think it's nice. I like it -- the engraving, milgraining, and ribbon prongs are lovely, but as Dreamer said, it's quite tall and I don't see a way to lower it. I don't foresee a new mounting for quite a long while, though, so hopefully I won't whack it on anything!
I had my 23rd Street ring made at the Santa Monica location. They weren't using CAD at that point. I basically just sent them a picture of the ring I wanted and they made it. There was not much discussion and the ring looks exactly like the one I asked for. They're certainly pricey (I think I paid 2k back in 2008, so more than Leon, I'm sure), but the customer service was solid and the product great.
I still have no idea what was going on with Lockes, but they had tons of personnel changes and then just disappeared. I don't know if they exist in some other form -- I think they were diamond siteholders -- but that ring was a beautiful design. Too bad things went south!