Cravin My Emerald cut
Shiny_Rock
- Joined
- Dec 30, 2007
- Messages
- 183
One of my friends got engaged over Christmas. Her ring is from Birks (her fiance lives in Canada) and looks like this http://www.birks.com/index.asp?SKU=854584&SecID=64&CatID=712&LangID=1
Let me preface this story with the fact that she doesn''t know if the ring is white gold or platinum, she doesn''t know what size the diamond is, she doesn''t know the specs. It is a beautiful ring though. My guess is that the diamond is 0.3-0.5 carats as it''s not much wider than the band. Sparkles like crazy.
I was talking to her and one of our other friends about diamonds. We saw this lady with a massively large diamond...which started this whole discussion. They asked me what size I wanted and when I said 2 carats it launched what I felt was an "attack" on me. My unengaged friend was saying how my fingers were so small (size 6) and that would look huge. I responded with "well emerald cuts show smaller for their weight than rounds" and I personally thought that size looked great (I felt 3 carat was bordering on too large). My engaged friend asked how much a diamond that size would cost and when I replied about $15-18K she went off about how "there''s no way you can get a good quality 2 carat diamond for that price...people buy huge stones that are crap..etc etc".
I wanted to ask her how someone that doesn''t even know a single detail about her ring (except for the cost probably) knew what the stone I want would cost. Granted I am fine with G/H color and want VS1/VS2 but as long as the stone is well cut that is by no means a "crappy" diamond. I simply do not plan on paying for a brand name.
I was so frustrated by this and wonder if they''ll criticize my ring (when I get it just because it''s big. Most of my closer friends have round or princess cut rings with center stones of 1-1.5 carats. A few people I work with have slightly larger rings and I don''t feel that a 2 carat would be too big for my "circle."
Anyone else had a similar situation?
It''s so nice to be able to vent here...
Let me preface this story with the fact that she doesn''t know if the ring is white gold or platinum, she doesn''t know what size the diamond is, she doesn''t know the specs. It is a beautiful ring though. My guess is that the diamond is 0.3-0.5 carats as it''s not much wider than the band. Sparkles like crazy.
I was talking to her and one of our other friends about diamonds. We saw this lady with a massively large diamond...which started this whole discussion. They asked me what size I wanted and when I said 2 carats it launched what I felt was an "attack" on me. My unengaged friend was saying how my fingers were so small (size 6) and that would look huge. I responded with "well emerald cuts show smaller for their weight than rounds" and I personally thought that size looked great (I felt 3 carat was bordering on too large). My engaged friend asked how much a diamond that size would cost and when I replied about $15-18K she went off about how "there''s no way you can get a good quality 2 carat diamond for that price...people buy huge stones that are crap..etc etc".
I wanted to ask her how someone that doesn''t even know a single detail about her ring (except for the cost probably) knew what the stone I want would cost. Granted I am fine with G/H color and want VS1/VS2 but as long as the stone is well cut that is by no means a "crappy" diamond. I simply do not plan on paying for a brand name.
I was so frustrated by this and wonder if they''ll criticize my ring (when I get it just because it''s big. Most of my closer friends have round or princess cut rings with center stones of 1-1.5 carats. A few people I work with have slightly larger rings and I don''t feel that a 2 carat would be too big for my "circle."
Anyone else had a similar situation?
It''s so nice to be able to vent here...