shape
carat
color
clarity

Help, Ladies; ring & size advice!

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

DeBaillou

Rough_Rock
Joined
Feb 21, 2008
Messages
13
Hi all- thanks in advance for any advice. This is definitely the best set of forums, educated folks, and helpful people I have come across in the diamond/ring communities I have found on the web
face1.gif
.

Here''s my situation: I am hopelessly in love with a wonderful woman, and she with me. We have been together for over a year now, although we have been friends for about 2.5 years. I have no doubt that I want to marry her, and have been secretly educating myself on purchasing a nice stone and setting for a couple of months now. We are both very big on surprises, and both share the opinion that it is ideal for a guy to pick out a ring (assuming he has good taste and they have similar taste) in secret. I have a stone and setting picked out (asscher in platinum- see below), but don''t know her ring size. She is 5'' 6" tall, weighs a muscular 127 (she used to be a gymnast), has what I would describe as a normal to slightly small hand with slightly stocky fingers (stocky is such a terrible description; her fingers are beautiful!). She does not wear any rings, and I don''t think she even has any that I could secretly borrow to size. I don''t think I could size her finger while she sleeps (she will undoubtedly wake up). I don''t want to buy another ring or an adjustable toy ring to size her finger with- she is pretty sly and would likely see through that trick.

As far as I can tell, I only have two options to keep it a secret: 1.) buy the ring slightly larger than I estimate her size to be (maybe a 6.5?) and have it resized if necessary, or 2.) ask a close friend of hers to sneakily get her size somehow.

Option 1 is nice because no one but me will know, but bad because the chance of guessing her exact size is small. Resizing is really not a terrible issue; it will be free, but will mean no ring for her for a few days.

Option 2 is nice because I can find out her real size, and order the ring accordingly, but inherently dangerous because I have to let someone else know. She has one close friend that I know likes me a lot, and would probably be able to keep the secret. I thought she could take my girl out for a shopping trip, and, while having her own ring cleaned, have some "fun" by each of them trying on rings or finding sizes- something like that. Another critical bit of info. is my timing- the proposal will be sometime in the next 6 months, so her friend will have to keep a secret for an extended time period. A plus to this is that any suspicions she may have while sizing rings with her friend may dwindle when the proposal doesn''t come directly after (as an aside, please don''t think I will be disappointing her by waiting this extra time; it is most likely sooner than she would expect anyway!).

Whew! Any advice ladies? I would love to hear things from a woman''s perspective. Is it better to buy then resize? Could you keep a secret like that for 6 months if necessary? Any other options I haven''t thought of? Thanks so much for letting me ramble; this is such an important deal to me- she is so perfect!

Also, what do you think of this ring? I am crazy about it and am 99% sure she will love it.

Thanks for your help!!!

rz1.jpg
 
I say go with option 1. It sounds like you are really insisting on surprises, and I think with option 2 there is a bigger chance of her putting the two together. Your design doesn''t have any details on the bottom, so resizing will not be an issue.

Good luck! I''m sure she will be amazed! If it''s small, make sure she doesn''t jam it in with excitement. My friend did just that, and they spent the next 30 minutes trying to get it off her finger...She was very frustrated for not having the next 2 days, but she lived
1.gif
 
Hi DeBail :) welcome to pricescope
35.gif


I know there have been some ingenious ways of getting ring sizes on the sly (if you do a forum search I am sure you would find some :))

I would be hesitant to guess the size in case you are way off but I would also be hesitant telling a friend a secret is easily let out even if one person knows it is the whole "OMG don't tell so and so but guess what I heard..."

Could you possible measure her finger in her sleep with some string? I am stumped for other suggestions but I am sure you will get others :)

ETA physical stature has absolute squat to do with finger size
7.gif
 
Hi there! And congratulations on your upcoming engagement!

Here are a couple of thoughts:

1) Is she a deep sleeper? If so, get a piece of thread or ribbon and carefully wrap it around her ring finger while she sleeps. Mark the EXACT spot where the thread meets itself (so, white thread or ribbon could help) and then use one of the internet''s online ring measurers to get her size. I''ll hunt around and see if I can post a link. You probably won''t get it exactly right with this method, but you''ll get a great approximation that can be re-sized.

2) If she has a friend you can trust, it might not be a bad idea to take her into your confidence not only because of the ring size, but also to just make sure that your idea doens''t need veto-ing. E.g., say your lovely girlfriend has said to her bestfriend "Lord, I really HATE asschers. Whatever Mr. Beloved gives me, I sure hope it''s not an asscher!" then you will want to know this, right?

Some of us best friends can be trusted! My bff''s boyfriend asked for help and I managed to get a whole range of info from her without her having the SLIGHTEST clue. Just depends on the gal, I guess. And you can get that info from your girlfriend with a casual convo about which friends can / can''t keep secrets.
 
What a beautiful ring! I love the Asscher cut!

Personally I''m the same way. I want my guy to pick out a ring I know he has good taste and I know I''ll love whatever he picks out. I would go with option number 1. The ring can always be re-sized and it sounds like the surprise is so important to you both that I wouldn''t risk letting a close girlfriend in on it, especially if the proposal could be up to 6 months out.
 
Thanks for your thoughts! I will probably go with option 1; guessing her size plus a little extra to keep it a surprise. This is a nerve-wracking process, but she is worth all of it and more. I appreciate your advice!
 
Option #1 is the safest, and as long as re-sizing is at no extra cost, I think she'll be so happy with being newly engaged, the ring sizing will be over before you know it!

If you really want to be sure (and if you really want to be sneaky) you could goof around with her in the kitchen and put twist-ties around ALL her fingers, and all of yours, and just pretend you're in a silly mood (but keep the one IMPORTANT twist-tie after you remove all the others)
 
Mediterranean; Good idea with the twist ties! I have been considering a similar approach- thinking of string games or something of the like that would involve all or most of her fingers so there is no suspicion. This is a tricky process...

You ladies are a great sounding board and it''s nice to hear your advice. Thanks!
 
Keep in mind there is a certain tolerance a ring can take when it comes to re-sizing. The setting you have picked has many small side stones and resizing changes the way they are held in place. Those small pave stones become very vulnerable to falling out if the ring gets sized more that 1/2 size up or down. Check with the jeweler about this in case you decide to guess at the size.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top