I’m *FINALLY* pulling the trigger…

[msop04]

5.5 mm sides:

6.0 mm sides:

And, yes, I broke both of them in the process!

 

[yssie]

5.5mm sides wins for me. Makes the centerstone stand out a touch more.

 

[MissGotRocks]

Definitely the 5.5 for me as well - isn't it strange how so little size difference can have such an impact?

 

[mrs-b]

Hi @msop04 - this is getting exciting!

I would normally say that the 6mm sides are my preference - but only if the tilt was more pronounced. However, the design of a wrap-style ring makes tilt more difficult to achieve for side stones, as it opens up the gap between the sides and the center, so smaller sides with less tilt will be a better way forward, in my opinion.

There are pretty much 2 camps on three stone rings: smaller sides so the center stands out as the star of the show - or - larger sides so the three stones contribute more equally and the sides have more presence. Normally, I prefer option 2 - but not in this instance (ie a wrap design).

And I think the sides set with 3 prongs look smashing! Do you have a rough timeframe till this is completed? I'm currently waiting on a pair of earrings, but it will probably be two more weeks yet, and I'll be climbing the walls by then!!

Definitely enjoying this journey with you!

 

[msop04]

…

There are pretty much 2 camps on three stone rings: smaller sides so the center stands out as the star of the show - or - larger sides so the three stones contribute more equally and the sides have more presence. Normally, I prefer option 2 - but not in this instance (ie a wrap design).


And I think the sides set with 3 prongs look smashing! Do you have a rough timeframe till this is completed? I'm currently waiting on a pair of earrings, but it will probably be two more weeks yet, and I'll be climbing the walls by then!!

Definitely enjoying this journey with you!

Thank you! I’m so glad I went ahead and had David do this CAD - even when I thought I knew better! HA!

This is exactly where I am with this decision. I’m almost always in the “center is the star” camp, BUT I do love that the 6 mm sides gives more traditional 3 stone proportions… and more “look.” Each is super comfortable, so that’s not an issue at all.

So my dilemma is… do I want “more aestheticallly pleasing on my finger,” or do I say “to hell with aesthetics! This is a wrap! Gimme that WALL OF BLING!!!”???

Jewelry can be hard, man. #firstworldprolems #stillproblemstho

 

[mrs-b]

Good morning, @msop04

My 3 stone had a (roughly) 9.35mm center (ergo smaller than yours) and 6.35mm sides (ergo larger than your 6mm sides iteration). I would defy ANYone to say that ring wasn't aesthetically pleasing!!









The sides provide more balance to the center stone, but I don't believe it falls into 'wall of bling' territory - which always makes the look sound slightly vulgar and garish to me.

So here's my COTT (Cards On The Table) moment: when this 3 stone variation is done, you will already HAVE a solitaire. What's the point in doing a second ring where it's basically another solitaire - with accent sides? Isn't the whole design so you can have more variation? If you WANT to be able to add accents to the sides of what is essentially a solitaire - and also remove them at will - then do smaller sides. But if you want a whole other look, I'd go back to considering the 6mm sides. But I would make very, very sure they can be sufficiently angled without it producing a gap between center and sides, and I *would* consider lifting the center so the sides can be more tucked in - even if it means remodeling the center to make it possible.

So I've now done a 180 - but ONLY providing it's possible from a design perspective.

Three Stone Sisters - ROCK ON!

 

[AllAboardTheBlingTrain]

Good morning, @msop04

My 3 stone had a (roughly) 9.35mm center (ergo smaller than yours) and 6.35mm sides (ergo larger than your 6mm sides iteration). I would defy ANYone to say that ring wasn't aesthetically pleasing!!









The sides provide more balance to the center stone, but I don't believe it falls into 'wall of bling' territory - which always makes the look sound slightly vulgar and garish to me.

So here's my COTT (Cards On The Table) moment: when this 3 stone variation is done, you will already HAVE a solitaire. What's the point in doing a second ring where it's basically another solitaire - with accent sides? Isn't the whole design so you can have more variation? If you WANT to be able to add accents to the sides of what is essentially a solitaire - and also remove them at will - then do smaller sides. But if you want a whole other look, I'd go back to considering the 6mm sides. But I would make very, very sure they can be sufficiently angled without it producing a gap between center and sides, and I *would* consider lifting the center so the sides can be more tucked in - even if it means remodeling the center to make it possible.

So I've now done a 180 - but ONLY providing it's possible from a design perspective.

Three Stone Sisters - ROCK ON!

I agree with this. I usually prefer 3 stones where the side stones play more of an accent stone role, but in your case, since it’s a wrap, if it’s feasible I’d go for the larger sides. Might as well as make both looks as distinct as possible!

 

[msop04]

Good morning, @msop04

My 3 stone had a (roughly) 9.35mm center (ergo smaller than yours) and 6.35mm sides (ergo larger than your 6mm sides iteration). I would defy ANYone to say that ring wasn't aesthetically pleasing!!









The sides provide more balance to the center stone, but I don't believe it falls into 'wall of bling' territory - which always makes the look sound slightly vulgar and garish to me.

So here's my COTT (Cards On The Table) moment: when this 3 stone variation is done, you will already HAVE a solitaire. What's the point in doing a second ring where it's basically another solitaire - with accent sides? Isn't the whole design so you can have more variation? If you WANT to be able to add accents to the sides of what is essentially a solitaire - and also remove them at will - then do smaller sides. But if you want a whole other look, I'd go back to considering the 6mm sides. But I would make very, very sure they can be sufficiently angled without it producing a gap between center and sides, and I *would* consider lifting the center so the sides can be more tucked in - even if it means remodeling the center to make it possible.

So I've now done a 180 - but ONLY providing it's possible from a design perspective.

Three Stone Sisters - ROCK ON!

SPOT. ON.
Your three stone ring was the epitome of of all three stones… perfection. Everything you said is how I’m feeling! I have a solitaire… It is my preference, after all. This wrap is to be for fun and more bling, so I guess I’ll just have to do myself a solid and have the bling! Thanks for the perspective and vote of confidence, @mrs-b!!

It’s looking like the 6’s are in the lead!!

 

[DiamondGal28]

I love the 6's too! This is going to be one heck of a project!

 

[mrs-b]

SPOT. ON.
Your three stone ring was the epitome of of all three stones… perfection. Everything you said is how I’m feeling! I have a solitaire… It is my preference, after all. This wrap is to be for fun and more bling, so I guess I’ll just have to do myself a solid and have the bling! Thanks for the perspective and vote of confidence, @mrs-b!!

It’s looking like the 6’s are in the lead!!

@msop04 - for what this is worth - one day I'll change my Beloved solitaire into Beloved x 3. I intend to add sides of a very similar proportion to what I had in my 3 stone - so the proportions will be more or less identical - but the overall weight will be bigger.

I'm a substantial woman with a substantial presence. I was done trying to hide, fit in, be discreet, or not draw attention to myself so as not to draw the disapproval of others years ago. Life is too short. You can be classy, elegant - even understated in your style - and still have a honking big ring. Rock it, girl!

 

[msop04]

I agree with this. I usually prefer 3 stones where the side stones play more of an accent stone role, but in your case, since it’s a wrap, if it’s feasible I’d go for the larger sides. Might as well as make both looks as distinct as po

@msop04 - for what this is worth - one day I'll change my Beloved solitaire into Beloved x 3. I intend to add sides of a very similar proportion to what I had in my 3 stone - so the proportions will be more or less identical - but the overall weight will be bigger.

I'm a substantial woman with a substantial presence. I was done trying to hide, fit in, be discreet, or not draw attention to myself so as not to draw the disapproval of others years ago. Life is too short. You can be classy, elegant - even understated in your style - and still have a honking big ring. Rock it, girl!

And this is why we love you.
Thank you for the vote of confidence… and I mean that sincerely, as I have struggled with this for years.

SIX. IT. IS.

 

[msop04]

My ring enjoying Mexico…

 

[Taylorbug!]

My ring enjoying Mexico…

Would love to see profile pictures and the rings separate. Enjoy your Vacation!

 

[Kim N]

Wow, this turned out amazing!

 

[SparklieBug]

Would love to see profile pictures and the rings separate. Enjoy your Vacation!

I second this! Gorgeous ring, and it looks perfect on your hand!

 

[Slickk]

Holy cow! It’s spectacular!!! What a great job. Beautiful stones!! Enjoy your vacay and new bling!!

 

[Gussie]

WE NEED MORE PICS STAT

 

[OdetteOdile]

Woo hoo!! It looks amazing!!

 

[KristyDarling]

Perfection! You nailed it!

 

[mrs-b]

This ring combo is EVERYTHING. And those proportions are the bomb.

Gorgeous. GORGEOUS! Congratulations!! <3 <3 <3

 

[oncrutchesrightnow]

Amazing!

 

[msop04]

Real life perspective (if only real life included being in paradise every day).

 

[msop04]

WE NEED MORE PICS STAT

Would love to see profile pictures and the rings separate. Enjoy your Vacation!

I second this! Gorgeous ring, and it looks perfect on your hand!

Thanks! I really love it. I'm sending back to DK early next week to make some minor adjustments, but I'll post lots of pics as soon as it's perfection (it's almost there now, but we *are* PS members, so...).

 

[msop04]

Wow, this turned out amazing!

Holy cow! It’s spectacular!!! What a great job. Beautiful stones!! Enjoy your vacay and new bling!!

Amazing!

This ring combo is EVERYTHING. And those proportions are the bomb.

Gorgeous. GORGEOUS! Congratulations!! <3 <3 <3

Perfection! You nailed it!

Woo hoo!! It looks amazing!!

Thanks, ya'll!!

 

[Taylorbug!]

Have you got your ring back from DK? Do you mind sharing more pics? I want to do a three storne and trying to decide which option would be best for me!

 

[LLJsmom]

Wow!! Missed this @msop04 . Congratulations!! That is a spectacular 3 stone. So happy for you that you went with it. I love wearing a 3 stone. The horizontal finger coverage is such a satisfying feeling. Enjoy for many years to come.