shape
carat
color
clarity

Idealscopes Are IN....................

mdmc

Shiny_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jan 27, 2010
Messages
209
Need your expert advise please.
Look at the attachment and me know
 

Attachments

Sorry the first and last ones got switched.
The first picture is #1534327 This was the gemologists #3



The second is # 1536986 This was the gemologists #2


This was the third picture #1531312 This was the gemologists #1
 
Just going by the picture and what the gemologist said, I agree with them. My favorite is the 1st diamond I just love those arrows! Considering (according to the gemologist) it performs better and looks whiter than the others, I suggest going with that.
 
mdmc|1358194835|3355411 said:
Sorry the first and last ones got switched.
The first picture is #1534327 This was the gemologists #3



The second is # 1536986 This was the gemologists #2


This was the third picture #1531312 This was the gemologists #1

Hm...ok...well I'd still stick with what they said...
 
Here is what he said.
I'm happy to tell you that you have more than one great option to choose from. Our gemologist's personal favorite is diamond 1531312 (1.21crt J VS2). It has great light performance and performs the brightest of your selections. It has a true "J" color, possessing only a faint warmth to its color. It's eye clean and will look fantastic in any setting.


Diamond 1536986 (1.20crt J SI1) is also a fantastic option, and ranks a close second in terms of light performance. It is very bright and has great light performance as well. Its feather blends well and its inclusions give it a very slight haze, but the gemologist is rather certain that the average eye will view it as eye clean. If you prefer the diamond to be just slightly whiter, this will be your better option, as it has a higher "J" color.


I am leaning toward #2 since he said it was eye clean and "whiter" than #1 I also looked at the GIA report. All inclusions shown on the report are on the edges of the diamond.
 
I'd go w/ #1 - such minute colour differences in this size range aren't going to make any real-world difference in how it looks once set, when you aren't looking at both side by side, and "slight haze" would worry me.
 
Any one else?
 
Yssie|1358197827|3355467 said:
I'd go w/ #1 - such minute colour differences in this size range aren't going to make any real-world difference in how it looks once set, when you aren't looking at both side by side, and "slight haze" would worry me.

I agree, 'slight haze' would be a no go for me!
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top