Ganesha
Shiny_Rock
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2011
- Messages
- 177
mimi72|1333289644|3161126 said:princessfeedme, thanks for asking the question, I did want to comment on the SI1 clarity since we so often hear that with step cuts you "have to" go with VS clarity or better. I respectfully disagree. One has to look VERY closely and up close to see a couple of faint pepper-like specs in this EC stone. It doesn't affect the performance. In fact, I thought it was so clean I was thinking of sending it back to the GIA to get regraded b/c I thought maybe it could be VS2. But when I got it appraised, the "graduate gemologist" appraiser said it's definitely an SI1.
For performance, I think it's far more important to get the proportions right. And maybe color too? I love low colored antique cushions and even RBs, because of the colorful flashes/chunky color, but maybe higher color is better on a step cut? ALTHOUGH I have to immediately take that statement back, because a couple of years ago the JBeG owner who posted here (Erica? Grace?) had a STUNNING L or M color asscher made into a 5 stone by LM. That ring was/is a Pricescope classic (now owned by another lucky PS'er). So I guess I go back to getting an excellent cut.
Bottom line - an SI1 step cut, even a big one, should not be immediately excluded. Like any diamond, you need to see it to know. They can be a great value!
mimi72|1344958250|3251274 said:jbgirl, irisheyes, Tuckins...Thanks for your compliments! I am still loving my ring after having it for a few months now.
Sadly, just a couple of days ago I noticed that one of the delicate claw prongs has broken off. I don't remember snagging it on anything. I have yet to contact Leon since I don't really want to ship it back to NY and not have it for a couple of weeks but that's what I'll have to do. Don't know if they will take care of the repair or if it will be on me.