Need help finding a pear cut diamond

[furiousone]

I have been looking for a pear cut diamond for a while . It appears the online sources are cheaper however I cant view them in person. Because of this I could use some help on determining which or if either are good buys .

1) 1.21ct 2) 1.18ct 3) 1.08 ct

Color D G E
clarity SI2 SI2 SI2
depth 62.7% 61.5% 63.1%
girdle ThinToThick VeryThinToThick ThinToThick
cutlet None None None
polish Verygood Good good
symmetry good Good veryGood
flouresence SB None None
measurement 9.55x5.87x3.68 (1.62 L/W) 10.16x5.95xx3.66(1.70) 8.81x5.77x3.64(1.53)
table 56% 56% 58%
$4200 $3900 $4800

Also is there any sites that are better than others ?

 

[FireGoddess]

Have you tried searching for a diamond using the Pricescope search tool? You can see how your prices compare.

Attached is a chart from gemappraisers.com about good stats for pears.

I still recommend seeing a stone if possible - or having the vendor tell you if the SI2 grade on your diamond is eye-clean (and personally, not just from 10 inches away, from like 2 or 3 inches away), whether there is a strong bowtie or not (strong bowtie - not a good thing). Don''t commit to a stone till you''ve seen it (put a deposit or something and have them ship it to you, or pay with contingency that you can return it within 10 days if you don''t like it).

The strong blue fluor in the D stone could be a problem if it makes the stone look milky. Otherwise, it could look really nice. That may be why the D is discounted somewhat, so it''s something I''d ask.