quaeritur
Brilliant_Rock
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2004
- Messages
- 1,238
Wow... I hadn't kept up with this thread. First, let me just say AGAIN how absolutely adorable your puppy is, Mara.
Second, I really enjoyed reading about the training philosophies. F&I, I agree with so much of what you said, and I share your passionate invective of dog-dumping and passionate support of rescue.
Let me start by saying I don't have anywhere near the qualifications of either F&I or Mara's trainer, I can only offer my own experience with my dogs. Bentley, the nearly 7-year-old male, is very strong. We are his third home. First home, he was tied out from puppyhood, malnourished, unvaccinated, and heartwom infested. He ran away to the neighbors, who took him in and later purchased him from the original owner. They had him treated, neutered, and took him to obedience classes. In just over a year with them, he went from a skittish, unsocialized mess, to a confident, loving family member that was a dream around the two children (4 and 7) in the household. Sadly, he developed a certain enjoyment of the hunt, and after killing off their chickens and a goat, the family decided he might do better away from a farm. He went into rescue, and six weeks later, came home with us. We took him to clicker training classes, agility training classes, basic, intermediate and advanced obedience classes. Bottom line, he did GREAT with clicker. BUT, he also needed to go to boot camp. We always enforce our alpha status with him (well, both dogs, actually). He never walks through doors ahead of us, he waits for his meals, he is only allowed up on furniture with our permission. He thrives with these subtle yet consistent rules. Every once in a while, he tests us, and we've found the best way to remind him of his status is to make him do pushups.
.
Our little girl, on the other hand, is a sensitive soul. She withers under a softly spoken "no." We only have her do pushups for treats and use almost all positive reinforcement in her training. She's earned her Canine Good Citizen certificate, and was on her way in agility until she developed arthritis at the tender age of two
.
Bottom line... get to know your dog, and you will find the best way to train it. Read everything and explore all training options. I'm a firm believer that the best method is some mix of training ideas and new inventions, tailored to each dog. Not the easy answer for many, but then again, if it were easy, we wouldn't have shelters. Wouldn't it be AWESOME if more pet owners were as conscientious as Mara?!
PS... F&I: polite leash walking still eludes us with Bentley... any suggestions?!
Second, I really enjoyed reading about the training philosophies. F&I, I agree with so much of what you said, and I share your passionate invective of dog-dumping and passionate support of rescue.
Let me start by saying I don't have anywhere near the qualifications of either F&I or Mara's trainer, I can only offer my own experience with my dogs. Bentley, the nearly 7-year-old male, is very strong. We are his third home. First home, he was tied out from puppyhood, malnourished, unvaccinated, and heartwom infested. He ran away to the neighbors, who took him in and later purchased him from the original owner. They had him treated, neutered, and took him to obedience classes. In just over a year with them, he went from a skittish, unsocialized mess, to a confident, loving family member that was a dream around the two children (4 and 7) in the household. Sadly, he developed a certain enjoyment of the hunt, and after killing off their chickens and a goat, the family decided he might do better away from a farm. He went into rescue, and six weeks later, came home with us. We took him to clicker training classes, agility training classes, basic, intermediate and advanced obedience classes. Bottom line, he did GREAT with clicker. BUT, he also needed to go to boot camp. We always enforce our alpha status with him (well, both dogs, actually). He never walks through doors ahead of us, he waits for his meals, he is only allowed up on furniture with our permission. He thrives with these subtle yet consistent rules. Every once in a while, he tests us, and we've found the best way to remind him of his status is to make him do pushups.
Our little girl, on the other hand, is a sensitive soul. She withers under a softly spoken "no." We only have her do pushups for treats and use almost all positive reinforcement in her training. She's earned her Canine Good Citizen certificate, and was on her way in agility until she developed arthritis at the tender age of two
Bottom line... get to know your dog, and you will find the best way to train it. Read everything and explore all training options. I'm a firm believer that the best method is some mix of training ideas and new inventions, tailored to each dog. Not the easy answer for many, but then again, if it were easy, we wouldn't have shelters. Wouldn't it be AWESOME if more pet owners were as conscientious as Mara?!
PS... F&I: polite leash walking still eludes us with Bentley... any suggestions?!