katebar
Brilliant_Rock
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2006
- Messages
- 1,566
Date: 1/7/2008 11:16:22 PM
Author: Sparkalicious
These are all so incredibly beautiful DB!
In a strange way I am glad that I am not in your position. I would go madif I actually had to make that choice. I would want all of them!!
They really all compliment your finger or maybe it is just the grace with which you wear them. The one your DH said was too big for your finger is a tad big, however, I have no doubt that you would be able to rock that bad boy and make it work. It is gorgeous!
I am so excited thinking about the choice you have before you ... Please keep us updated. I can''t wait to see which one you decide to adopt into your lovely jewelry family.
Edit -- Question: What is your criteria? What are you looking for to satisfy your upgrade requirement? Something you fall in love with or are you looking for a particular caratage etc, in addition, to something you fall in love with?
Date: 1/7/2008 11:17:43 PM
Author: LadyAmythyst69
Date: 1/7/2008 10:42:52 PM
Author: DiamanteBlu
Here I am with the 29.?? cushion, the 21.16 asscher and the 13.?? carat cushion [also D FL, can''t find the cert!]
Can''t believe I''m gonna say this because asschers are my thing but...I''m not sure I like the 21 ct asscher. It looks too much like the doorknobs on my Grandma''s old house! (Sorry! Now the asscher gods will smite me.)
Sorry to your hubby but that massive cusion looks GOOOOOOD on your hand. In this pic it looks really natural & not freakishly huge or anything. Of course it IS freakishly huge - but you can carry it off.
The big cushion is just prettier than the smaller one - nothing to do with size - just the way the stone looks. From the pics at least.
Date: 1/7/2008 11:39:28 PM
Author: Green with Envy
Who ever made that doorknob comment about the huge asscher... darn you! That is all I can see now too- especially with the side pic/hand shot. My grandmother use to have glass doorknobs that i LOVED... you can buy them at Anthropology and I always check them out while in that store.
I am not tring to say this in a nasty way (even though I AM GREEN WITH ENVY)... but since cost clearly is not a factor...
how ARE you going to decide on just one?? What are the factors? they are ALL great color, cut, clarity, yada yada yada.
I feel crazy saying this... but if you are sticking with a white diamond... I think the ONLY ONE that serioulsy looks like an UPGRADE next to your beautiful Rb... is that huge 29ct cushion. The ''too big on your hand'' comment about that one should be tossed out the window because wearing ANY of those rocks might knock somone out. I guess since DH might have something to do with paying... his opinion matters a tiny bit... but THAT huge cushion is THE ULTIMATE UPGRADE.
Everything else sort of looks same (in a very good way!) but different shape.
I also like the 10 ct cushion with pave around it... but I think this is because style is just different than other solitiares. Even you say for yourself that in real life your current e-ring looks as good as the 10 ct on your finger.
Sooooo... go for the gold and get the 29 ct cushion!!!!
-------------
ok- just read your last post. if 29 ct stone is the upgrade to this current upgrade... I agree and try to find the best 10ct cushion out there!!!
Date: 1/7/2008 11:45:45 PM
Author: Matata
iwanttheparaibaiwanttheparaibaiwanttheparaibaiwanttheparaiba, can you hear my heavy breathing, i know you can''t heart my heart beating because it isn''t, i think i''m unconscious, somebody pinch me, where''s my debrillator?iwanttheparaibaiwanttheparaibaiwanttheparaibaiwanttheparaiba
I''m casting my vote for something akin to the 29 carat cushion. There''s something funky looking about the 10 carat one. In one of the pics it looks like it has fisheye.
Date: 1/8/2008 4:43:41 AM
Author: Po10472
what a decision to make. If it were my choice, I''d go for the Kaufmann, its just stunning, second in the running would be the royal asscher, however that would be an uber upgrade from my wee 0.5ct EC so if I were in your Manolo Blahniks I''d go all out and get the 29ct cushion. You could just dive into it and bathe in its beauty. Whats your DH''s preference?
Also, were you staying in a nice hotel in NY........we need the other details of your trip too to allow our hearts to stop beating so.
Date: 1/8/2008 5:49:28 PM
Author: lovewhitediamonds
My vote hands down is for the RA... c''mon, it''s hard enough to find any RA''s let alone a 21 CARAT!!! That stone is a true ''piece of art'' and a very RARE one at that. What a treasure -- and it can only go up in value!
I don''t think there would ever be asscher ''shrinkage'' with that beauty! Who said asschers face up small?!
Date: 1/8/2008 7:37:04 PM
Author: fleur-de-lis
DiamanteBlu, thank you so much for sharing the photos of your trip! Not only are they exceptional stones, but the way you write is very transportive-- I felt excited just reading about your day.
Of all of them, IMO the ones that looked the best (most elegant, impressive, not trying too hard, etc.) were the ones that didn''t break 100% finger width coverage for the center stone. Sure, the 29 carat is mind-blowing, but it was like the ring was trying to wear your hand than the other way around, heh heh. IMO, I liked the look of the Kaufman 10 carat square emerald''s stone (though the bullets seem to be overkill IMO) and the 13 carat square emerald at leviev on your hand. They looked... confident, but not overcompensating; you know what I mean?
Similarly, though I liked the 10 carat cushion and it might be just me, might the setting be kind of taking away from the stone? It reminds me of the Harry Winston which a few posters here selected for their e-rings (I think ''AngelaInJapan'' was one), which seems lacy and I adore for cushions in the 2-3 carat range. I might be the only one, but it seemed TOO lacy with such an exceptionally large stone. That 10 carat can stand on its own and would probably have a greater impact without the additional quasi-halo adornment when viewed from the top; for some reason, the way it is reminds me of when a beautiful woman is wearing too much makeup...
... that said, those are some amazing options at your fingertips! Yay DiamanteBlu! How exciting!
--fdl
What a great narrative about how you and your DH are sorting through this purchase decision. I do have a couple questions which I highlighted. You mentioned a discount - how does that work? We''d all love a discount, so any advice is welcomeDate: 1/8/2008 9:58:25 PM
Author: DiamanteBl
Getting a stone of this magnitude is not a trivial exercise [or expense, for that matter]. You do not wander in one day and say: ''Oh, I think I''ll take that one.'' LOL! There are a number of sources: retail, antique dealers and auction houses. You don''t really go mad but you are under pressure from the vendors that are competing for your business so that can cause some stress.
Each stone I saw was magnificent in its own right and all the stores certainly want a customer to buy from them. A few have emailed and a couple have already called. I will call them back tomorrow.
Not everything I saw or posted is a candidate. I looked at some of the pieces because they were just spectacular specimens.
As far as what criteria to use . . . hopefully I can tell you my thought process.
First, some background . . . I have always loved minerals in general and precious and semi precious stones [since kindergarten or so]. I have been collecting stones and jewelry for about 45 years and have experience in siversmithing, goldsmithing and jewelry making and design. When I was in mergers and acquisitions I did quite a bit of work in the jewelry industry so I know many in the industry [in the US and in Italy primarily]. I love large stones and fine workmanship and I have also always wanted a yellow diamond. LOL! I''m not sure where the desire for a yellow came from but I have been coveting them since I first saw some at Shreve Crump & Low back in the 1970''s!
In any case, to me, the first thing to consider is how much finger coverage do I want for every day wear. At this point I am not looking for a special occasion ring. It looks like the sweet spot is in the 10 - 14 carat range. So . . . that would exclude those magnificent larger specimens [the 29 c cushion and the 21 c asscher]. They were to big for every day wear and were a factor of 3 higher in the ''list'' price than the smaller [I use the term loosely] stones.
Once you have established the size you need to decide on the shape/color/clarity. In the running for both of us are cushion and asscher/step cut stones. DM still favors RB''s. I''m not so sure. I would consider an Eightstar but in a smaller size than a fancy. Note that I have always wanted a cushion. I have a reasonable step cut EC and a RB. And then you have the debate con color and clarity. DH wants to go with D-E-F and VVS1 or 2 or better yet I am more ''flexible'' [read - I like larger stones as long as they are gorgeous]. Also, for a primary stone I would stick with a white diamond. Much as I love the yellows, I think that if/when I get one it would be for a RHR. Such a ring would be a ''self-purchase'' [like my EC! LOL!].
Am I rambling? Sorry - I am still trying to shake this flu and am a tad tired!
I guess the bottom line is that after you decide on size, you need to decide whether you are buying ''the paper'' or a beautiful stone. To me, the answer is that you want to buy a beautiful stone. As I posted in another thread, when you see ''your'' stone you will know it. I had been looking for a larger stone [5ish carats] for about 2 years back in the mid 1990''s when I wandered by a store in Palo Alto, no less! and saw my EC. It drew me in and I knew it had to be mine. I looked at it, put a deposit on it, went back to ''visit'' it a few times and then bought it. The stone was just calling out my name - DiamanteBlu, I am yours, take me home with you, pleeeeez!
I believe that the stone you are destied to have hill cause that kind of emotional reaction - especially when you are dealing with larger pieces that are less commoditized.
The two stones I felt that pull from were the 21 c asscher [a true masterpiece!] and the 29 c cushion. Unfortunately, both are a tad over the top in size for daily wear for me at this point [DH tells me that when I am 65 they will be appropriate! Snarl!] and the prices are more than we are prepared to spend at this pont even with the discount.
The KdS asscher was beautiful but I am not sure it was screaming my name. The price is right, though. The Graff EC would have to grow on me [too long and skinny - it would give me a complex! LOL!] so I think that it is out. We will see what cushions they come up with out of London. The 10 c cushion was nice but again was not screaming my name. I should have paid more mind to the 13 c cushion. I didn''t even get its cert! And the 13 c asscher was nice but, again, was not calling me.
I have to tell you, that I think I am tending to a cushion or maybe an asscher like the 21 carat but in a smaller size [14ish maybe?]. This is not easy. I am going to need to head down again to relook. I may have been in overload.
Oh, and I also do not like DeBeers so I would be very happy to get something that does not involve them!
I''ll be happy to elaborate if you have any further questions.
Date: 1/9/2008 10:35:58 AM
Author: canuk-gal
HI:
I can understand your interest in cushions--in this size range for me it would be a cushion or oval. Love the curves!! Thanks for sharing your trip!
cheers--Sharon
First, you need to remember that these are high priced boutiques. Graff is vertically integrated, except for mining, and Leviev is totally vertically integrated. Their margins are more robust, shall we say, so there is more "room" for flexibility. At higher price points my experience has been that marked prices are generally negotiable [except, possibly, at Tiffany I hear - LOL!] especially in the boutiques. This holds for high ticket items besides jewelry too. I''m sure you have had experience not paying sticker price when you buy a car? It''s kinda like that.Date: 1/9/2008 12:35:22 AM
Author: Beacon
You mentioned a discount - how does that work? We''d all love a discount, so any advice is welcome.
Also, do you get to find out the history of the stone you buy, as in literally where it was mined and if it went through deBeers hands? I imagine at this level, the stones are very well known to the selling house and the diamond trade. Can you actually avoid deBeers?
I am interested also in what security matters you faced. Did you call them in advance for an appointment or just walk in? I was interested to see the tray containing so many fantastic stones in one spot. Often jewelers are loathe to display so many at one moment on a tray, at least in my observation. It is very interesting to live vicariously through your experience. Thank you for all this fun insight!!!
Well, in a perverse sort of way, I''m glad that your DH is not quite as perfect as I would have liked to believeDate: 1/13/2008 5:32:03 PM
Author: DiamanteBlu
Date: 1/9/2008 10:35:58 AM
Author: canuk-gal
HI:
I can understand your interest in cushions--in this size range for me it would be a cushion or oval. Love the curves!! Thanks for sharing your trip!
cheers--Sharon
DH is back on his Eightstar RB kick. Sigh . . .
I told him I''d buy a cushion myself [RHR?] if he insisted on a RB! LOL!
That would be hilarious! Maybe you should agree to the RB just so you could get both.Date: 1/13/2008 5:32:03 PM
Author: DiamanteBlu
Date: 1/9/2008 10:35:58 AM
Author: canuk-gal
HI:
I can understand your interest in cushions--in this size range for me it would be a cushion or oval. Love the curves!! Thanks for sharing your trip!
cheers--Sharon
DH is back on his Eightstar RB kick. Sigh . . .
I told him I''d buy a cushion myself [RHR?] if he insisted on a RB! LOL!
Well, in a perverse sort of way, I'm glad that your DH is not quite as perfect as I would have liked to believete:[/b] 1/13/2008 6:51:11 PM
Author: isaku5
<Generous but so stubborn in a passive aggressive kind of way. He is definitely willing to buy you the RB of his dreams. Does he care that his dream is not yours? Not really. He wants to bring you away from your dream cushion and persuade you any way he can, that he's right! If he's going to spend 10's (or 100's) of thousands of dollars on a ring, he can hold out for as long as it takes..
In similar kinds of 'discussions', but definitely not similar dollar figures, I have learned that every time I would mention cushion, he would counter with RB. It now becomes a game: How to win him over to your way of thinking? Definitely not easy, but I think I read in one of your posts that you've been married for quite a while (way to go, btw!!) so you know the way he thinks by now and probably too how to get around his PA ways.
Now's the time to start working your magic so that when the perfect TDF cushion comes along (you've found it by yourself), he will be wooed by this fabulous stone and really believe it was all his idea ( I didn't know a cushion could look like that). You'll have to have your vendor on board with your plan. Manipulative??? Maybe ( depends on your definition), but well worth it? You'd better believe it!! And anyway, it was his choice!!! It's all about winning sometimes
That would be hilarious! Maybe you should agree to the RB just so you could get both.