shape
carat
color
clarity

Oh no.......

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

schmoopy

Rough_Rock
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Messages
14
First of all, I want to introduce myself and say what a great time it had been to pop by and read the topics in this forum! I have oggled over many of your rings and jewelry pieces! Lucky ladies! (And gents!)
35.gif


And secondly, I am wrestling with myself about my new almost-on-my-finger engagement ring. I must start out by saying that my dear fiance''s great grandmother left each of the great grandchildren a diamond for their engagements. She was a very worldly woman, who, in my opinion was the epitome of all that is royal and regal! I was so blessed to have met this wonderful woman and had the opportunity to become both friends and jewelry-pals! My Liam is the last of the 6 great grandkids to become engaged. We recently found out instead of leaving a stone, she left a vintage ruby bracelet (which I was FASCINATED with!) and a sum of money of which we were to use on an engagement ring, and an engagement ring ONLY! (she voiced a very direct opinion on that) I could only imagine what that was, Liam''s 5 cousins all have gorgeous ring, but that is beside the point.

We had begun the hunt for the "perfect" ring about 4 months ago. We made the mistake of heading to Tiffany''s for a look. Wowzas! I tried on a few rings, and I couldn''t believe how much I felt like a princess!! Hee hee!! If anyone is familiar with the twin cities area, JB Hudson''s is a popular stomping ground for engaged couples. We ended up there and began looking at stones, I was ecstatic when I saw a 3.01ct asscher! (and 3/01 being my birthday made it even more neat!) My dear fi kept saying maybe something a bit more.......maybe something a bit larger. Each time I wanted to both slap him on the knee
21.gif
. After about 2 hours of trying on rings and looking at diamonds, I fell in "like" with a 6.05ct brilliant cushion. I say fell in "like" because with my "size 5 1/2 on a hot day" fingers, I thought the cushion looked, well, frankly completely ridiculous. After a while, it started to grow on me, so we left for lunch. Liam kept saying that he wanted something that 1) I liked, that was most important 2) Evoked timeless beauty and grandeur (sp?) 3) and was unique. He knows I am not one to "upgrade" or trade-in sentimental things. I still have and wear the small silver band he gave me for our 1 yr "anniversary" back in high school!!! We went back and found a combination of settings that I loved - that was the important part to me, after seeing all the different styles of rings here I have become infatuated with settings!!! I decided on an all pave ring, with double prongs and a slightly curved basket. (Like a stretched out "u" if that makes sense??) Still indecided on the diamond. Or so I thought. That was back before christmas.

I now know I am getting the setting of my dreams with the cushion cut stone. Liam is so very proud of his choice, the cut color everything! I am very afraid and here are the reasons why....
I don''t want to lose a stone of that size!! Eeek! It makes me nervous just thinking about how much is sitting right there on my ring finger! (He says that is what insurance is for....)
All of my girfriends have very nice engagement rings. A few have gotten married and have lovely sets. I took 3 of them to see my engagment ring (stone unset) after an afternoon of dress shopping and they all said "hmph, that is sooooooo outrageously gaudy." in a rude tone.
8.gif
And one even had the guts to talk badly behind my back and say that we will never make it, I am way to materialistic! Ugh! They don''t even know the half of it.... These girls have been in my circle of friends since preschool! Liam''s family and friends had seen the ring and they ALL agree that it is very beautiful, and will be cherished/handed down for years to come. Which I agree! After all, it will be worn on MY finger so I am happy to hear good things about it!
And after doing much research on pricescope - many searches ending in "too big" or "age appropriate diamond" I am freaking myself out about this ring. The last thing I want is for us to be dubbed as materialistic people, or snobs. We both have graduated college and have very good jobs. We built a home in a prestigous area and I bought myself my first fun car. (2005 audi TT) I had always wanted one! I know its not much, but I had a Galant that was getting close to retirement!

I am not so much worried as to what others will think of my ring, but more worried what I should do to help cope with the "haters??"

Sorry to make my first post to long, I could have went with the "hi, glad to be here!" instead of the "hi, glad to be here," and eight years later wrap up my first post!! Anyway, thanks so much for listening, and advice would be great!
19.gif
 
First of all, love the name (that''s my one of the many nicknames my bf calls me). Second of all, you go girl! Your ring sounds fantastic. I think it is a rare thing for someone to say that their ring is too big and they wish for a smaller one no matter how much it looks like you are wearing a doorknob on your hand. The ring will be fantastic. If the ring were an heirloom then people would not be talking as much. If people say, ''oh wow, that''s REALLY big'' (in a not nice tone) just say, thanks, isn''t it beautiful. In fact, say that to everyone who has any snotty, jealous remark.
It''s your ring given to you by the man you love, so don''t sweat the small stuff and enjoy it!
 
Well, in many respects you can say it is already an heirloom. Afterall, your sweet FI''s grandmother bought it for you. It was her express wish. There will always be people around you who are jealous or petty in one way or another. If you love the ring, then don''t sweat it. If you don''t like the ring, then there should be some time to select comething else, but not necessarily something smaller. It''s up to your firends to be real friends to you or not. With any luck, you can weed out the "or not''s" pretty quickly. Congratulations on your upcoming engagement.
 
Your story and it''s sentiment is beautiful (except for those nasty girls). It sounds to me like your ring IS an heirloom in a matter of thinking since you are following the wishes of his grandmother. It also sounds like your ring does suit your lifestyle. Cherish it and love it and all that the ring represents. Forget those jealous girls. Jewelry is a matter of taste, and it may not be your friends'' taste, but I bet it looks amazing on you!! If one of your friends is wearing a dress that you would not wear, do you tell her it is gaudy and ugly? If she is carrying a designer purse or wearing designer shoes, do you tell her that she is pretentious and materialistic?? Of course not!!!! There is no accounting for class and manners, and it sounds like these "friends" have none.

This choice is between you, Liam, and his grandmother. She sounds like a wonderful woman to emulate with her royal and regal manner. The "friends" should mind their own business and manners.

Please show us pics as soon as possible!!

9.gif
 
The question is -- are you going to love wearing this ring? Are you going to be comfortable wearing it? When do you plan to wear this? Is this a ring that you plan to wear on an every day basis? On special occasions only?

That''s what you''ve got to figure out -- and I don''t think your friends, or your fiance''s friends and family can help you out there. Since you your fiance''s great grandmother has given you two the means to buy your dream ring, figure out what that is and buy it.

Ignore what everyone else thinks and get what will make you happy. I think that was the purpose of your fiance''s great grandmother giving you the money to do this in the first place.
 
Thank you all for your kind words!

ammayernyc - I''m a Schmoopy too!! My fi loved seinfeld! Thats where it came from! :)

Gale - thanks for the congrats! As for the "or-nots" I so much hope that my girlfriends turn out to be the good ones, I am hoping they were just going through some bad PMS that day....
20.gif


kaili - I feel very fortunate to have been blessed at such a young age. Hopefully I will age as well with time as my fi''s great grandmother did. She was 102 when she passed this past fall, 102 and still spunky!! I will most certainly without a doubt slap pictures here as soon as I receive it!
 
Hi prettyinpave,

This will without a doubt be a ring I will wear at all times EXCEPT: when traveling, I will then only wear the wedding band. And when doing any volunteer activity which requires me to use my hands. I think wearing any type of ring that is a bit out of the ordinary size-wise is uneccessary when volunteering. As a family, we volunteer at our local soup kitchen for thanksgiving and help out with the toys-for-tots organization in our area.

As far as comfort level, yes I am comfortable wearing any ring that my love has given me, no matter the size, shape, color, whatever. This stone just took a little getting used to! I had to pop by after work a couple times to check in on it, and try it on in the stone holder a few times!!
28.gif
 
Then I say, go for it girl!
face23.gif
 
Holy cow! 6 carats!?! Congrats!

Your SO didn''t have to buy that ring himself right? His great-grandma left him money for a ring right? Well, just say it was passed on to you. If someone ever mentions something, just go, "Yeah, it was passed on to me. Aren''t I lucky?" If it was passed on, what can they really say?
 
i loved reading your story! i think that it is so incredibly sweet that your bf''s great grandmother took such thought and care to provide you with your dream ring- she sounds like a wonderful woman! and 6 ct cushion?!?! you should get it, just because i want to see the PICTURES. hehe, ok just kidding! but i am a cushion girl myself (though mine surely will not be anywhere near 6 ct!), and i think if you feel comfortable wearing that stone then forget what your silly friends think. and i hope your friends stop being so mean... sheesh. they should be thrilled for you! probably a bit jealous? obviously you want to honor the great grandmother''s wishes (and when it means big diamonds, who would want to go against her anyway?!)- so get what will make you happy. if that''s a big gorgeous cushion, then go for it!

i have a custom tiffany''s pendant (~1940) that used to belong to my bf''s grandmother, whom he was very close to. i posted about this in the LIW thread, but it''s a "1" made out of 10 little diamonds, as my bf always calls me his number 1, b/c that''s what his grandfather called his grandmother- thus the pendant. the diamonds are "floating" in glass. it''s so precious! the heirloom pieces are the best. it means so much to me because i know he was "saving" the pendant for the right person and because it belonged to someone who was so important to him growing up. how special your ring will be, no matter what you choose!

btw, i also loooooove the audi tt. i''ve been dreaming of that car for years now... but alas, it will have to wait a while as i am in medical school
39.gif
(i won''t say anything mean to you like your friends though, even though i am a bit jealous!
3.gif
)

hmm, how about pictures of your ring in the car? hehe
1.gif
 
hello schmoopy
35.gif


geez, she had the nerve to say you guys "will never make it"?

Sounds like a very, very jealous girl!!
29.gif


I will look FANTASTIC!! Don''t give a **** about what they say, they just have to deal with the fact that you will have a gorgeous ring on your hand. I can''t believe how rude they were. If they are your friends you should be able to tell them that you don''t like those rude comments, and they should get over the fact that you have a 6 ct rock on your finger!
I think it''s wonderful that his grandmother left that money for you both.

Congrats on your ring and engagement, make sure you post pics when it''s done!!
 
I think you should have the ring if you love it, and don''t worry about what "other" people will think. No ring is too big or too small, or too sparkly or too anything if it''s yours and it was given in love, which it sounds like yours will be. I think the story behind the ring is beautiful, and you should be proud to wear that diamond!
 
First of, congratulations on the upcoming engagement. Second, i do think that a 6 carat rock is definitely going to make a statement about your values, tastes, means, etc. From your post, i get the feeling, most of your friends are not wearing stones that size so it''s possible they''re jealous. It''s also possible, they truly find it gaudy but if they''re good friends, perhaps you can ask them to keep their opinions to themselves? It sounds like you have a good sense how to wear your future ring with grace, I too think wearing it to a soup kitchen for instance would be inappropriate. But if you''re comfortable with wearing it otherwise and it fits with your lifestyle, then why not?
 
Hi Schmoopy!! I agree with what everyone else has said --

1) it''s YOUR ring; only YOU have to love it

and

2) holy $@!%@! I can''t wait to see it!!!
31.gif



One more thought -- I live in MN too, and I don''t see too many rocks even CLOSE to that size here, so I would be prepared to get LOTS of attention.....(and if it gets to be too much for you, I could always "hold on to it" for you....
11.gif
)
 
Date: 3/22/2005 11:11:55 PM
Author: Minny
Hi Schmoopy!! I agree with what everyone else has said --

1) it''s YOUR ring; only YOU have to love it

and

2) holy $@!%@! I can''t wait to see it!!!
31.gif



One more thought -- I live in MN too, and I don''t see too many rocks even CLOSE to that size here, so I would be prepared to get LOTS of attention.....(and if it gets to be too much for you, I could always ''hold on to it'' for you....
11.gif
)
Thank you ALL for the kind sentiments! I am really glad I have you Sparkle lovers here to boost me up! :)

Icekid - a vintage custom pendant from Tiffany?! Love that!!! How beautiful! I think it''s sweet when grandfathers/mothers pass down their sentimental heirlooms! It makes giving and receiving that much more special!! As for photos of the ring IN the car, dear fi is ANAL about driving "summer" cars during the winter months, and with the lack of snow, I thought it would be alright to take ''er out for a spin. "What are you DOING?! All the SALT residue on the road??? Are you a crazy woman?!" LOL, ugh, and the auto drama starts.....!!

Minny - Hiya neighbor!! Yes, since becoming engaged I have noticed other women''s gorgeous rings...it has become a horrible habit! No matter what the stone, I still have to oooh and ahhh over everyone''s rings! It must be a "hey I just got engaged" sort of thing?? Speaking of attention, (a little off topic) we were out with friends for dinner last weekend at Maynard''s. Let me note that I am not a heavy drinker and I was NOT drinking at all that night. My dear went to get the car and as I was walking over to hop in, BAM! I slammed right into the pavement!! It was horrible!!! My ankle gave out on me and I went down right there in the middle of the drive in front of the restaurant. My purse went flying, it was so embarassing! I could hear Liam laughing hysterically in the car.....as I lay there laughing, 2 very nice older men came to my "rescue." It was hilarious! So as long as the attention is NOT that sort of attention.... I''m ok with that! Maybe we should have a play date with our sparklies!!
31.gif


I promise promise to post pictures, a little bird whispered in my ear that my ring should be done beginning of next week!! Hip hip horaaaaaaaay!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top