POLL: Which three stone oval do you like and why?

[derbygal]

I have a little obsession with shield-cut sides, but I think pears would be stunning too!

 

[two_little_birds]

What are these side diamonds called? I love them!

 

[Laila619]

Half moons are my absolute faces for ovals. But any of the Leon designs are dreamy.

Ditto, I love half moons!

 

[Enerchi]

Thanks for posting the DBL example - those are perfect chubby trillions, for sure!!

I love the trillion or pear options because to my eye, they extend and make the ring look more elongated. I find the rounded shapes of the ovals or 1/2 moons accentuate the rounded curves of the oval, and if you are sensitive about (what I would consider a PERFECT!!) 7.25 ring size, to me, the taper of trillion or pears, just minimizes the width that worries you.

 

[starshine]

Ooooo, so torn between bullets and half moons!!! Either of those are very attractive to me....half moons have a slight edge, so voted for that! Not a fan of ovals or trillants. I think the other 2 choices draw better attention to the center oval, kwim?

 

[starshine]

What are these side diamonds called? I love them!

I think those are called Cadillac cut.

 

[Niel]

Thanks for posting the DBL example - those are perfect chubby trillions, for sure!!

I love the trillion or pear options because to my eye, they extend and make the ring look more elongated. I find the rounded shapes of the ovals or 1/2 moons accentuate the rounded curves of the oval, and if you are sensitive about (what I would consider a PERFECT!!) 7.25 ring size, to me, the taper of trillion or pears, just minimizes the width that worries you.

Do you think bullets would have a lot of flashes? Or will the be small to have an attractive light return. I know they wont be as "sparkly ", but i like step cuts and the way the flash

 

[Enerchi]

hmmm... I don't know their performance well enough to advise on that. I do know baguettes are not as 'sparkly' so bullets would function in a similar way. More of a flash and a "slice" look, than a twinkle, which is what 1/2 moons, trillions, ovals would give you.

What I'd suggest is maybe if you are cruising DBL, look for rings with bullets and if they have videos, just see how they perform??? OR maybe GOG has a video on bullets in his library of videos???

I wish I could answer you better than that.. I'm sorry that I can't be more helpful...

 

[Niel]

hmmm... I don't know their performance well enough to advise on that. I do know baguettes are not as 'sparkly' so bullets would function in a similar way. More of a flash and a "slice" look, than a twinkle, which is what 1/2 moons, trillions, ovals would give you.

What I'd suggest is maybe if you are cruising DBL, look for rings with bullets and if they have videos, just see how they perform??? OR maybe GOG has a video on bullets in his library of videos???

I wish I could answer you better than that.. I'm sorry that I can't be more helpful...

Thsts ok good ideal ill go take s gander
hopefully somebody else will chime in tooo

 

[starshine]

AGBF's red spinel
[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/red-spinel.170312/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/red-spinel.170312/[/URL]

Revise my vote - this is the most beautiful ring ever! Pear sides would be perfect! And since you adore pears this might be a gorgeous option.

Hubba hubba!!! I agree and revise my vote, too! Wowza!!!

 

[diamondseeker2006]

AGBF's red spinel
[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/red-spinel.170312/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/red-spinel.170312/[/URL]

Revise my vote - this is the most beautiful ring ever! Pear sides would be perfect! And since you adore pears this might be a gorgeous option.

Hubba hubba!!! I agree and revise my vote, too! Wowza!!!

This is right on the list of my top few favorite colored stone rings EVER. I think pears and ovals work well together. The problem with three ovals with a large center stone is that the side ovals will cost a fortune if they are the size of the sample ring. I think the pears will sparkle more than bullets would, but I do love the bullets. I think you might like to have the contrast of sparkly sides with a colored stone, though. So half moons or pears might get my vote.

 

[meg_]

I love half moons, I think thats my favorite.

Your 5 stone image makes me drool as well.

 

[ClassyRocks]

Nielseel- link or pic of the dbl one you are lusting after??

http://www.diamondsbylauren.com/index.php/jewelry/yellow-diamond-y-z-si1-cushion-diamond-cut-for-color-antique-diamond-gia-r4448

I think i like it because chubby trillions just end up looking a lot like chubby pears.

I really like that pear ring its , hmmm, this was suppose to help me decide and now your just adding more


Those pics you posted are beautiful Rosebloom, i really like a lot of those, though im trying to avoid a halo, its too common (one of the reasons im disappointed in my pear) I would make it a 5 stone but my only concern there is that i dont have enough finger coverage

nielseel, I like this ring because it is not so "expected". It is classic and looks like a lot of thought was put into its design. It has that little bit of "extra" that makes it important.

I am excited for you!

 

[04diamond<3]

Half moons are my absolute faces for ovals. But any of the Leon designs are dreamy.

I am fairly certain thats going to be out of my budget But i love her work SOOO much. I considered either going with ERD or waiting longer and going with LM....But i think ERD does do nice work, and its a lot more budget friendly. Though i dont know just how bad a "bmw" price is

Leon Mege is a man but yes, his work is absolutely stunning! May I ask what the center will be? I love love love half moons with ovals because they're so unique and the added finger coverage is always yummy! More ovals would definitely provide the most finger coverage (depending on how big they are), but I also really love pear sides! Tough decision, but for me, it'd depend on what the center would be and what color.

 

[m-2-b]

I'm a big 3 stone fan and I'd love to see you make one w/ half moons!

 

[Niel]

Half moons are my absolute faces for ovals. But any of the Leon designs are dreamy.

I am fairly certain thats going to be out of my budget But i love her work SOOO much. I considered either going with ERD or waiting longer and going with LM....But i think ERD does do nice work, and its a lot more budget friendly. Though i dont know just how bad a "bmw" price is

Leon Mege is a man but yes, his work is absolutely stunning! May I ask what the center will be? I love love love half moons with ovals because they're so unique and the added finger coverage is always yummy! More ovals would definitely provide the most finger coverage (depending on how big they are), but I also really love pear sides! Tough decision, but for me, it'd depend on what the center would be and what color.

I am aware leon is a man. So glad you guys are on the ball correcting my typos

 

[chrono]

Pear or shield because they make the contrast with the center oval pop. A pair of pears will also be easier to find, not requiring special cutting so should cost less than the other shapes. They also face up large for the carat weight.

 

[04diamond<3]

Half moons are my absolute faces for ovals. But any of the Leon designs are dreamy.

I am fairly certain thats going to be out of my budget But i love her work SOOO much. I considered either going with ERD or waiting longer and going with LM....But i think ERD does do nice work, and its a lot more budget friendly. Though i dont know just how bad a "bmw" price is

Leon Mege is a man but yes, his work is absolutely stunning! May I ask what the center will be? I love love love half moons with ovals because they're so unique and the added finger coverage is always yummy! More ovals would definitely provide the most finger coverage (depending on how big they are), but I also really love pear sides! Tough decision, but for me, it'd depend on what the center would be and what color.

I am aware leon is a man. So glad you guys are on the ball correcting my typos

I'm sorry I really thought you were confused. Are we allowed to know what this ring will consist of?

 

[Niel]

I wasnt really looking to go i to the stone, i just wanted general opinions on the idea of an oval three stone.

Im leaning toward bullets but i just need some info on if they would be flat or perform like little ECs

 

[stargurl78]

I like half moons or pears for the sides. And I love the design of the 5-stone with the padparadscha by LM

 

[Niel]

Nielseel- link or pic of the dbl one you are lusting after??

http://www.diamondsbylauren.com/index.php/jewelry/yellow-diamond-y-z-si1-cushion-diamond-cut-for-color-antique-diamond-gia-r4448

I think i like it because chubby trillions just end up looking a lot like chubby pears.

I really like that pear ring its , hmmm, this was suppose to help me decide and now your just adding more


Those pics you posted are beautiful Rosebloom, i really like a lot of those, though im trying to avoid a halo, its too common (one of the reasons im disappointed in my pear) I would make it a 5 stone but my only concern there is that i dont have enough finger coverage

nielseel, I like this ring because it is not so "expected". It is classic and looks like a lot of thought was put into its design. It has that little bit of "extra" that makes it important.

I am excited for you!

arent you just the sweetest! I love the 5 stone a LOT, and i like the idea that its got a lot of diamond, so it feels really "engagementy" My only concerns are that 1, its too much stone for my finger size and center stone (wont fit) OR that the stones will be too small and wont have as much of an impact

 

[Kellybell]

I wasnt really looking to go i to the stone, i just wanted general opinions on the idea of an oval three stone.

Im leaning toward bullets but i just need some info on if they would be flat or perform like little ECs

Hi Nielseel!

Coming out of lurkdom to say that the oval with bullet side stone ring you posted is mine! Yay!

I would say that step-cut bullets are pretty subtle. I wouldn't describe them as "flat", but I do get more flashes of light versus sparkle. They definitely make an impact, but I agree with you that they need to be a certain size to get credit for the shine (and for the shape.)

I hope this helps! Let me know if you have any other questions about them.

Kelly

 

[Niel]

I wasnt really looking to go i to the stone, i just wanted general opinions on the idea of an oval three stone.

Im leaning toward bullets but i just need some info on if they would be flat or perform like little ECs

Hi Nielseel!

Coming out of lurkdom to say that the oval with bullet side stone ring you posted is mine! Yay!

I would say that step-cut bullets are pretty subtle. I wouldn't describe them as "flat", but I do get more flashes of light versus sparkle. They definitely make an impact, but I agree with you that they need to be a certain size to get credit for the shine (and for the shape.)

I hope this helps! Let me know if you have any other questions about them.

Kelly

AH!! I was hoping you would pop your head out Your ring is just absolutely mesmerizing! I hope you dont mind me posting it.

Yes I do have a few question. my pear gives off "sparkle" and i think i actually prefer the flashes of step cuts. You think your bullets are large enough to give off good flashes and emphasize the shape enough?? I would imagine they do but you know what "assuming" does

 

[Kellybell]

AH!! I was hoping you would pop your head out Your ring is just absolutely mesmerizing! I hope you dont mind me posting it.

Yes I do have a few question. What size are those bullets? And what is the length of your oval? my pear gives off "sparkle" and i think i actually prefer the flashes of step cuts. You think your bullets are large enough to give off good flashes and emphasize the shape enough?? I would imagine they do but you know what "assuming" does

Awww, you are so sweet!! Thanks for the compliments on my ring - I don't mind you posting it at all.

The bullets are 0.9 cts total weight, so 0.45 each. My oval is 9.63 mm in length. I do think my sidestones are big enough to get credit for both the shape and the sparkle (I had originally wanted to go smaller, but Leon thought these would be a better fit...I'm glad I went with his opinion.)

If you feel that your center stone gives off enough "sparkle" that you don't think you will need to rely on the side-stones for that extra "oomph", and if you think you would prefer the contrast of the step-cut side stones with the cut of your center stone, then I think they would be a great match (but I am pretty biased as that's the exact combo I was going for with my e-ring, so take that opinion with a grain of salt. )

 

[Niel]

AH!! I was hoping you would pop your head out Your ring is just absolutely mesmerizing! I hope you dont mind me posting it.

Yes I do have a few question. What size are those bullets? And what is the length of your oval? my pear gives off "sparkle" and i think i actually prefer the flashes of step cuts. You think your bullets are large enough to give off good flashes and emphasize the shape enough?? I would imagine they do but you know what "assuming" does

Awww, you are so sweet!! Thanks for the compliments on my ring - I don't mind you posting it at all.

The bullets are 0.9 cts total weight, so 0.45 each. My oval is 9.63 mm in length. I do think my sidestones are big enough to get credit for both the shape and the sparkle (I had originally wanted to go smaller, but Leon thought these would be a better fit...I'm glad I went with his opinion.)

If you feel that your center stone gives off enough "sparkle" that you don't think you will need to rely on the side-stones for that extra "oomph", and if you think you would prefer the contrast of the step-cut side stones with the cut of your center stone, then I think they would be a great match (but I am pretty biased as that's the exact combo I was going for with my e-ring, so take that opinion with a grain of salt. )

Yeah my center will be a colkred stone so im not too concerned about the difference in faceting. I did ask originally for your specs but then i just looked at your posts instead to avlid ypu having to repeat yourself. It really is a beautiful ring. What type of band do you wear with it?

Also yes of course i wanted to know the reason behind why your opinion on it
I love to hear people who actually have it in RL, not just in my head

 

[Niel]

found some settings with actual colored stones as the center. Im actually really loving the side ovals... rats.

 

[Enerchi]

hmmm... between the two above you just attached pics of... I'd also be all over the oval sides!! They just seem to be very elegant and sophisticated in that particular setting! Or maybe i'm swayed by the gorgeous prongs... its possible!

But I do love that oval look - and the proportion seems perfect to my eye between the centre and sides. Good ratio!

 

[Niel]

hmmm... between the two above you just attached pics of... I'd also be all over the oval sides!! They just seem to be very elegant and sophisticated in that particular setting! Or maybe i'm swayed by the gorgeous prongs... its possible!

But I do love that oval look - and the proportion seems perfect to my eye between the centre and sides. Good ratio!

I was thinking the same thing. Seems like its a whole different animal with a CS center. What is that ratio? It looks like those ovals are about half the size.

And as for the claw prongs, i WILL have those, regardless of how it ends up, they just make me melt

 

[Enerchi]

I'm "melting" along with you on those prongs... man, I love a good claw prong!!

 

[lambskin]

I just love 3 stone rings! There is something so balanced about this combination. I LOVE the 3 stone ovals for a RHR and bullets or baguettes for ER. For colored stone centered three stone rings, any side stone is fine except for trillions. I just can't dig those stones. They really look dead to me. I know that baguettes do not have much sparkle but the step cuts make it look interesting. I am old fashioned and try to make my important jewelery timeless.