Pricing help

[yennyfire]

Hi all,

I could use your expertise in helping me price these stones. I’ve attached the appraisal so you can see measurements and specs. The price is listed at replacement value and definitely very inflated imo. I included a photo of them in 4 prong mounting they were originally in for the faceting detail.

Since y’all are always scouring antique pieces, what would you say is a fair price for these earrings? I’be got them listed on LT for 3500, but would love your thoughts, as I’d like to sell them fairly quickly.

Thanks!