Resetting recently set diamond - need opinions

[facetgirl]

If its not too late. I think a simple solitaire would also look lovely. Maybe in a rose gold to make it pop

 

[marymm]

Wow, I really love that 4-lobed Ritani setting with the delicate pave/milgrain! I think it looks to really work well with your band (which I also love).

I think you said WF gave you a quote for that Ritani setting some months ago.. would you mind sharing it or providing a quote range so I get a rough idea of its pricing? I understand if you prefer not.

 

[MarionC]

Wow, I really love that 4-lobed Ritani setting with the delicate pave/milgrain! I think it looks to really work well with your band (which I also love).

I think you said WF gave you a quote for that Ritani setting some months ago.. would you mind sharing it or providing a quote range so I get a rough idea of its pricing? I understand if you prefer not.

Thanks, marymm! I'm glad you think it works. I really like both rings, but couldn't tell if they related well. This is what I love about PS - having a chance to get feedback in a meaningful way that's helps with the thought process.

No Problem - I think it was around 2600 in 18k or rose gold.

Jimmi



facetgirl, thank you for your suggestion. I'll take it to heart - but I may have already jumped into the deep end of the pool

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I really like that Ritani with the 4 petal halo a lot. I don't think it has milgrain, does it? But I would ask WF to ask them if it can be added if you go in that direction. I do think it needs it with your band (and I like it!!).

Aside from that ring, the rings that are going to go best with your band are Beverley K. They are delicate, have small diamonds, and milgrain.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

This is really pretty but I'd want the milgrain edge on it, too:

http://www.loveaffairdiamonds.com/the-gabbie-halo/

This is pretty but maybe too much to go with a fancy band:

http://www.loveaffairdiamonds.com/the-bella-halo/

 

[klokkeblomst]

Stuller makes a setting similar to the Ritani, but with more traditional prong placement, which I think makes it feel more delicate: http://www.stuller.com/products/122237/?groupId=120088

 

[starryeyed]

Stuller makes a setting similar to the Ritani, but with more traditional prong placement, which I think makes it feel more delicate: http://www.stuller.com/products/122237/?groupId=120088

One thing I noticed Jimmianne about your paper-Ritani is that the petal orientation is more like this Stuller setting. Maybe you should turn the paper and take a look again? Give us another picture!

I like that Bella Halo that DS posted too, although it's a plain shank. Gabbie is nice too. That orientation is like the Stuller.

 

[MarionC]

Hey DS, I'm glad you like it... your thumbs up on this project makes me happy.

So somehow, some way, after months of fooling around, missteps, doubts & hair tearing I'm going to order this today.
I can either mail the diamond back to WF or get a quote from my local Ritani dealer. Either of them will send to stone to Ritani,
so whomever can give me the best quote. I love giving WF business, so hopefully they can price-match.

 

[MarionC]

Stuller makes a setting similar to the Ritani, but with more traditional prong placement, which I think makes it feel more delicate: http://www.stuller.com/products/122237/????? sgroupId=120088

One thing I noticed Jimmianne about your paper-Ritani is that the petal orientation is more like this Stuller setting. Maybe you should turn the paper and take a look again? Give us another picture!

I like that Bella Halo that DS posted too, although it's a plain shank. Gabbie is nice too. That orientation is like the Stuller.

How could I have missed the prong orientation...I posted a new E-W paper ring.. with paper I can have a new ring every morning

Klokkeblomst, thank you for your suggestion. When I found side views of the stuller it was more of a halo than flower, but it's a pretty setting.

 

[starryeyed]

I may have to order that paper-Ritani in my size!

I think the new setting will look fantastic with your band. I would get pave in the shank and a milgrain finish, if possible.

I can't wait to see it all together!

 

[MarionC]

I may have to order that paper-Ritani in my size!

I think the new setting will look fantastic with your band. I would get pave in the shank and a milgrain finish, if possible.

I can't wait to see it all together!

My current price point for wonky paper rings is very reasonable, Starryeyed!

[edit]and the ice & twig pieces are on sale right now : )

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I like the design of the Ritani, too! Are you going to ask for milgrain to be added?

 

[teobdl]

OMG that Ritani floral setting is amazing . It's like a better version of the Tiffany Ribbon setting, which is a little wonky looking.

 

[starryeyed]

My current price point for wonky paper rings is very reasonable, Starryeyed!

[edit]and the ice & twig pieces are on sale right now : )

HAHAHA!

 

[MarionC]

OMG that Ritani floral setting is amazing . It's like a better version of the Tiffany Ribbon setting, which is a little wonky looking.

yay!

To DS - I'm not sure about the milgrain. I want to treat this ring as an independent RHR, not part of a set, so perhaps the more modern non-milgrain may work in my favor. I feel hesitant because I don't know how it would turn out, like maybe the milgrain on the band and the milgrain on the halo might not match.
WF said I can have the milgrain added later.
I"ll have to think about it.

The quote from my local dealer for 14k white gold w/o milgrain is $2200.
Have not heard back from WF yet.

Speaking of milgrain, I've had 2 experiences now - that cheap eternity band from China had "milgrain" that was just little slashes in the metal - very rough & ugly. Now with this band, there are 3 little round bumps per mm and it adds shimmer to the diamonds. I like it! So I am becoming a milgrain fan : )

 

[MarionC]

I ordered the Ritani "4-lobe" setting today. [!] I'm going to see how it looks without milgrain first, although DS's instincts are so good that I feel a little torn about my decision.
Anyway, 3 to 4 weeks from now I'll have both my PSPS [purchases since PS] set, in hand/on hand.

 

[starryeyed]

I ordered the Ritani "4-lobe" setting today. [!] I'm going to see how it looks without milgrain first, although DS's instincts are so good that I feel a little torn about my decision.
Anyway, 3 to 4 weeks from now I'll have both my PSPS [purchases since PS] set, in hand/on hand.

Congratulations!

So you must have gone with your local dealer?

Did s/he say if the milgrain could be added after-the-fact?

Can't wait to see your set!

 

[Daisyoz]

I am looking forwards to see it Jimmi. I had a crush with that setting in rose gold while researching my ering. It was love at first sight It is just not practical though for me to wear it on a daily basis with work ect. I can't wait to see yours

 

[MarionC]

I ordered the Ritani "4-lobe" setting today. [!] I'm going to see how it looks without milgrain first, although DS's instincts are so good that I feel a little torn about my decision.
Anyway, 3 to 4 weeks from now I'll have both my PSPS [purchases since PS] set, in hand/on hand.

Congratulations!

So you must have gone with your local dealer?

Did s/he say if the milgrain could be added after-the-fact?

Can't wait to see your set!

Thanks, Starry! It's quite a relief to have finally come around to deciding on the Ritani.

The local Ritani dealer was able to price match the online discounts & bank wire discount and more.
I think they might be interested in having me as an ongoing customer... I did let slip that I have a terrible diamond addiction

Milgrain can be added later.

Thanks for all the support during this process!

 

[MarionC]

I am looking forwards to see it Jimmi. I had a crush with that setting in rose gold while researching my ering. It was love at first sight It is just not practical though for me to wear it on a daily basis with work ect. I can't wait to see yours

Daisy, This setting would be awesome in rose gold.

I'll be back with photos in a few weeks!
yay!

 

[MarionC]

OMG that Ritani floral setting is amazing . It's like a better version of the Tiffany Ribbon setting, which is a little wonky looking.

I wonder if the same person designed both. I know that the Ritani designer used to work for Tiffany. I tried to look up the history, but could not find it. Maybe someone here will know...

 

[MissGotRocks]

I know I'm late here but just wanted to say I think you made a fabulous choice!

I think that ring will be gorgeous - with that band or even on its own! Can't wait to see it finished! I think you are gonna love it!!

 

[MarionC]

I know I'm late here but just wanted to say I think you made a fabulous choice!

I think that ring will be gorgeous - with that band or even on its own! Can't wait to see it finished! I think you are gonna love it!!

Thank you Miss GR
... never too late to hear the words "good choice".

 

[MarionC]

I have sold the ACA in this Ritani setting and am replacing it with a champagne OEC. Now is the time to add milgrain.
I was thinking of having is added to the outside of the "lobes" and the shank where the melee are/is. Would it also look good - or not - to milgrain the circle of metal directly around the stone. Because the stone has color I'm not sure what will look best.
thanks.

 

[teobdl]

I think an OEC will look great. The floral pattern is very fitting for the setting.

As far as milgraine, I could see both working, though I'd prefer also the inside of the lobes for a consistent look. I think having a smooth inside and milgain outside would be one too many features to take in... already have the interesting lobes, interesting mêlée, interesting prong orientation, interesting diamond (that contrasts the mêlée) and then you'll have milgraine. Better to keep the features simple by consistency so the shapes and textures speak for themselves.

 

[MarionC]

I think an OEC will look great. The floral pattern is very fitting for the setting.

As far as milgraine, I could see both working, though I'd prefer also the inside of the lobes for a consistent look. I think having a smooth inside and milgain outside would be one too many features to take in... already have the interesting lobes, interesting mêlée, interesting prong orientation, interesting diamond (that contrasts the mêlée) and then you'll have milgraine. Better to keep the features simple by consistency so the shapes and textures speak for themselves.

thanks, teobdl for your thoughtful response.
It will really be fun to see how this turns out.