shape
carat
color
clarity

setting materials

Kitten35

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 18, 2011
Messages
343
Hi everyone,
thanks for the help so far with the spinel setting project. I have it down to 3 settings--2 at a B&M and one Heart of Water.

I have a question about setting materials. my stone needs a white metal to look it's best--too much YG brought out the yellow/orange modifiers in the spinel, whereas the white metals/and or/sidestones make it pop. This has been the general opinion from everyone I have talked to at B&Ms when we have tried settings (and I've been to about four of them this week).

I own almost no white gold--I don't generally care for it because of the replating that always needs done. To me, if I'm spending that much, it shouldn't need so much maintenance. IN fact, I only have two white gold pieces--one was given to me. My other pieces are silver if they are white. I love YG for it's warmth and low maintenance, most of my stuff is that, but this stone really needs a white setting. Platinum I actually love, but that is way too expensive right now. I have read on here about palladium but never seen or used it before.

I wouldn't mind the 14K WG if we were going to be staying in the area--the jeweler told me the price included all maintenance including dipping and sizing without purchasing an additional warranty or anything like that (it was not a "maul" jeweler btw). But we are moving overseas in five months and so I'd have to pay for the dipping each time, which I really don't want to do. I don't know how fast my skin would take it off because I only have two pieces so far--one was poor quality to begin with, and the other is a pearl so I only wear it for a few hours at a time.

What are the pros and cons between palladium, silver, and WG? If I were to just let the rhodium wear off, would it look too yellow? I'm especially interested in palladium.

Questions:
1. Can anyone post pics of it?

2. *BIG ONE* CAN it be resized? Is it brittle?

3. Why don't many manufacturers make things in silver? Will it not hold the jewelry as well? I have a beautiful piece in silver I had made last year and it's still a bright white, with little maintenance outside of my polishing cloth. Why is it "looked down" upon in the jewelry world--is it really "inferior" for holding stones, etc or is it just because it's not as expensive and people think it's "cheap?"

4. Would you recommend palladium if you were moving overseas vs. white gold? Forgive my ignorance--but is it well known outside the USA? Can jewelers work with it? We have some great local jewelers here, but I don't know what we'll find outside of that, or how much more it might cost to have it plated every time in a different country (Germany) where cost of living is significantly higher than it is here.

5. Or, would you save up for platinum? I could get a plain Tiffany style solitaire for about $600 from Blue Nile or find a used setting on Ebay perhaps. I'm considering this route. I'm planning on a plain solitaire probably, but I would prefer to keep prices around $450 or less. The two quotes I had for WG setting were around this price at my B&M, because they are having a sale.
 
When palladium "wears" over time, it ends up looking sort of darkish gray. It is also very light.

1. See link:
[URL='https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/palladium-v-platinum-v-white-gold.139075/']https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/palladium-v-platinum-v-white-gold.139075/[/URL]
https://www.pricescope.com/journal/overview_common_alloys_used_jewelry/

2. Palladium can be resized and isn't brittle. It is durable for everyday wear, pretty much like platinum.

3. Silver is very soft, so it cannot hold large stone with fine prongs. Also, most silver tarnish easily so becomes to high maintenance for most people who want to just wear and forget about it. Also, not everyone can handle silversmithing.
 
Thank you!

It is true that the silver pieces I have I do not wear often, so I don't know how durable that would be for something I am planning on wearing most everyday.

Can anyone help with knowledge of palladium outside the US? I'm sorry if thats a silly question. I have been overseas, but never lived there (We are moving to Germany in August). Will a jeweler there know how to work with it--in the sense of, is it used there as much?

Also, does anyone have pics so I can see what it looks like in a ring?
 
I can't answer your questions about palladium, but have you considered just not plating your white gold? It would be more of a creamy white than a bright white.
 
Have you thought about palladium white gold? The palladium in the alloy makes it much whiter (although more of a steely grey/white) and a lot less likely to cause skin reactions than the traditional formula. It works pretty much like normal gold alloys, although with a very high melting temperature, which rather surprised me the first time I tried the alloying recipe.
 
Where can I get the alloy? Do I have to get it from certain vendors or can anyone mix it?

I am right now looking at a solitaire from Unique Settings of NY. The jewelry store I talked to this morning said it probably would not come unplated, and probably couldn't be ordered that way. I think I may just let the finish wear off over time and if I don't mind it, then just let it be. I can always get it re-dipped if it really drives me crazy, but judging from the pictures on here of unplated, I really don't think it will bug me that much. It still looks quite different than yellow-yellow gold to me. Has anyone else ever just let the rhodium kind of wear off over time?

I am also considering just going with the WG, since that seems to be more common. With my H being in a job that moves us around every three years or so, I can't really get regular maintenance from the same place and from what I understand WG is much more common than palladium so it may be difficult to find a jeweler every time we move who could work with it. I'm still thinking of a secondhand, platinum setting, but the prices are SO stinking high right now so this is more realistic right now. But I can dream, right? haha.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP

Featured Topics

Top