DoodlesLife
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2021
- Messages
- 9
I want to thank everyone who participates in this forum - I learned more than I would've ever imagined about diamonds! This is my first post so please let me know if I am not posting it to the right thread.
After searching and researching yellow diamonds for months, it seemed like I found the one - GIA report 2175225056. I know may not be perfect, but the price was reasonable and it's everything I was looking for, so I decided to purchase it.
Report:
www.gia.edu
I received the ring today, and it is gourgeous. However, after a loupe examination, I found a small cut/chip on the side of the stone, which I can feel with my nails. I reached out to the jeweler, and they are telling me that it is an open feather, so nothing to worry about. Here's the problem: maybe I am not correct, but it was my understanding that GIA grades feathers as feathers if they don’t break to the surface, and if the feather is open to the surface, then it would be graded as cavity/etc. and marked green. I don’t see any of that on the GIA report - all the feathers are red.
Am I wrong? Can feathers break to the surface although they are red on the report?
I absolutely love the ring, so I really don't want to return it. But I am worried about the structural integrity of the stone.
Here's the photo of the chip:

After searching and researching yellow diamonds for months, it seemed like I found the one - GIA report 2175225056. I know may not be perfect, but the price was reasonable and it's everything I was looking for, so I decided to purchase it.
Report:
GIA - Report Check
I received the ring today, and it is gourgeous. However, after a loupe examination, I found a small cut/chip on the side of the stone, which I can feel with my nails. I reached out to the jeweler, and they are telling me that it is an open feather, so nothing to worry about. Here's the problem: maybe I am not correct, but it was my understanding that GIA grades feathers as feathers if they don’t break to the surface, and if the feather is open to the surface, then it would be graded as cavity/etc. and marked green. I don’t see any of that on the GIA report - all the feathers are red.
Am I wrong? Can feathers break to the surface although they are red on the report?
I absolutely love the ring, so I really don't want to return it. But I am worried about the structural integrity of the stone.
Here's the photo of the chip:
