Update - video and pics of the 2 cushions!

[NJC84]

Hi PS friends!

ok here is the video of the two cushions im considering. a square cushion brellia was put in (far left) just for the comparison. its the middle and the right one im considering. pics of the two are below as well. would love your feedback!! thanks

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5OD4ePyios&feature=youtu.be

 

[tyty333]

I prefer the 3rd one in the video which I think is the first one in your pictures.

I don't like that other stone...it reminds me of a concave colored stone which I don't care for (personal preference) .

 

[Enerchi]

Seems as tho in these still photos, the chunkier one is on the left. The diamond I prefer in the video is the far right one.

Which are you leaning towards?

 

[Roxy]

From the video I'd choose the one on the far right. It's labeled as 1.22 F SI1 .

In the pictures it's the one on the left.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

In the actual video, the stone on the far right. I think it is really a nice one!

 

[marymm]

Okay, I'm the outlier - in the video I much prefer the one in the middle, and in your first post above, it's the one on the right.
(To my eyes, there is something not symmetrical going on in the chunkier cushion that everyone else likes.)

 

[Roxy]

Okay, I'm the outlier - in the video I much prefer the one in the middle, and in your first post above, it's the one on the right.
(To my eyes, there is something not symmetrical going on in the chunkier cushion that everyone else likes.)

I'm so glad you commented Mary! This is a perfect example of why we're always urging people (who come to PS for guidance) that they've really got to see the diamond in action for themselves.

Whether in person or via a video, the actual performance of a diamond is rather subjective & it depends on what appeals to each person's eye. And I'd bet you're not the ONLY "outlier" out there!

 

[two_little_birds]

Okay, I'm the outlier - in the video I much prefer the one in the middle, and in your first post above, it's the one on the right.

I agree, the middle one is my favorite too!

I don't like the one on the far right because of the "cross" in the middle, it's far too distracting for me.

As for the first stone, on the far left, it's beautiful but just doesn't grab my attention like the one in the middle does.

 

[stargurl78]

Okay, I'm the outlier - in the video I much prefer the one in the middle, and in your first post above, it's the one on the right.

I agree, the middle one is my favorite too!

I don't like the one on the far right because of the "cross" in the middle, it's far too distracting for me.

As for the first stone, on the far left, it's beautiful but just doesn't grab my attention like the one in the middle does.

Another vote for the middle one! I normally like chunkier cushions but I agree with two_little_birds - I don't like the "cross" in the middle of the stone either. I honestly would probably keep looking but if you are definitely picking from these 3, I like the middle stone the best.