ChunkyCushionLover
Ideal_Rock
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2009
- Messages
- 2,463
Date: 10/6/2009 1:45:21 PM
Author: Gailey
Well there's definitely a lot of extra baggage you have to take into account when you choose Leon, you will have seen all the threads. That being said, I have never seen a Leon piece that I didn't love and I don't think I have ever read about poor workmanship from him.
>>> Yes I would have to fight both price and to make sure all details were listed in the work order if I chose him. I didn't like the loops he used in his design of the round aquas design I wanted them hidden so I was concerned he would make me pay a lot more to have all loops hidden, wanted more for the detachable part, more to add diamonds between the leverbacks and the smaller cushion etc etc.
His TOB offend some, as does his attitude. Neither of those would put me off if I was set on him. That being said I have had no significant dealings with him.
>> Doesn't offend me that much either as I micromanage every little detail of the projects, down to the clarity of the melee and all the measurements and I would know if he had a problem with the design before I even sent a deposit.
I have had lengthy e-conversations with Ocean and she is an absolute delight and I think she will execute your project beautifully. To clarify, the only reason that my project with her has not progressed is because of issues with my centre stone (nothing to do with Ocean), and I ran out of time to devote to the project before my working season began.
>>>>>> She is even more pleasant on the phone.
You mentioned one thing that set alarm bells ringing in my head and that was about weight. Trust me, no woman wants to end up with saggy ear lobes, no matter how fabulous the earrings, so choice of metal ought to take overall weight into consideration.
>>>> I am completing a graduate degree in physical chemistry so I decided to look into this weight issue a little bit.
The assumption I make is that Gold and Platinum alloy does not have intermolecular forces accounting for an appreciable change in density due to alloy mixing and I know its a reasonable one:
I calculated the Density of 18k Gold Alloy (Assuming 75% Gold, 18.5% Silver, 1% Copper, 5.5% Zinc) to be 16.91g/cm3
I read from experiment the Density of Platinum 900 (90% Platinum and 10% Iridium) to be 21.53g/cm3
Based on this platinum 900 would be 27% heavier than 18K WG.
Ocean estimated 7g of 18k white gold needed per earring. The Diamonds weigh 0.65 carats and the Aquamarines Weigh 3.35 carats. So total weight about 7.8g.
If I use Platinum it would be closer to 10g.
My fiances wedding ring weighs about 5g so the earrings would be twice as heavy in platinum as her platinum ring! Well I think thats pretty substantial I think I better go with the 25% lighter 18K WG.
Both 14K and 18K white gold are routinely rhodium plated. I asked Wink, other than cost, was their any noticeable difference between the two. His reply (and I quote) was 'None'. Begs the question, why spring for 18k when to all intents and purposes it looks the same as 14K. Now I understand you are creating a very special piece for what will probably be one of the most significant moments in both of your livesl, so your choice of metal may want to reflect that. But I still wouldn't want to run the risk of saggy lobes for the sake of creating an heirloom.
18k gold is softer, less brittle and easier to work with for jeweler's to do handmade. 14k and 10k really can only be cast so for handmade work 14k is out of the question and most jeweler's don't reccomend it including Ocean.
- 18k also in my opinion has a greater luster and a whiter color (probably due to the silver content) (my opinion based on seeing rings it might be the plating job was better with more expensive 18k gold though).