Small update on the purple garnets.
They mentioned the potential for silk, and it might be more than a negligible amount, but they cannot be sure until they cut. They very kindly offered to cut the pair with no expectation from me to buy them. Then they can give me all the details and I can see the finished result, and then decide.
Unfortunately they can't do one of their precision oval cuts due to the roughs not being deep enough, plus the oval precision cuts apparently tend to darken tone. So they'll be cut into standard ovals - still well-cut but will show the extinction I was worried about. We will see to what degree.
Here is one of their precision jobs (green tourmaline) vs their standard ovals (garnet).
Overall I am grateful for their honest communication on clarity and cut options, and the offer to cut without committing me to the purchase was an unexpected surprise.
They mentioned the potential for silk, and it might be more than a negligible amount, but they cannot be sure until they cut. They very kindly offered to cut the pair with no expectation from me to buy them. Then they can give me all the details and I can see the finished result, and then decide.
Unfortunately they can't do one of their precision oval cuts due to the roughs not being deep enough, plus the oval precision cuts apparently tend to darken tone. So they'll be cut into standard ovals - still well-cut but will show the extinction I was worried about. We will see to what degree.
Here is one of their precision jobs (green tourmaline) vs their standard ovals (garnet).
Overall I am grateful for their honest communication on clarity and cut options, and the offer to cut without committing me to the purchase was an unexpected surprise.
Last edited: