CAD feedback: which sidestone size?

[Niel]

Well first and foremost I honestly think this is stunning and the perfect version of this style of this stone. I can tell they are rounds and cushions and I think the design flows well even being two tone. Amazing.
mask him about having the prongs hug the stone more so there is into a gap. That may be a function of the cad but you never want to assume.
I think the second version is a little bit more flattering. Nothing looks “too small “ or “too big”. Goldilocks.
will you be doing anything to the donut (millgrian maybe) or leaning it all plain.
God I love this so.

 

[Rfisher]

Mmmmm
Its lovely!
I like the second version better, as it also changes where the cathedral knife edge ends up not so high, as it’s between prongs of the sidestones.

 

[petit_bijou]

Thanks for your feedback @Niel and @Rfisher!

I will see if the prongs can hug the stone a bit more without losing the swoopiness from the gallery view. I was planning to leave the donuts plain - I know I had milgrain in the initial vision, but as I go down this path the more I'm appreciating the fluidity of the design.

 

[Niel]

Has this ring been finished I’d love to see