shape
carat
color
clarity

Choosing between two WF stones

CrisM

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Jul 28, 2011
Messages
153
I'm torn! They both meet my parameters:
*Near colorless
*eye clean by WF standards, up to 6" viewing from the top and profile view as it will be set in a tension setting
*under 13k
*as close to 7mm as I can get
*eligible for an upgrade

Here they are:

1.294 G VS2
http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-3045749.htm
Size: a 7mm stone! Yipee!
Color and clarity: G VS2 is totally mind clean for color and clarity
Idealscope: I thought the center showed leakage but Liza assures it can't be seen with the naked eye and calls it a technical difference more than a visual one. She's compared the stones in person.
Cost: Within budget though if it were an H and all else the same, it would lower the price tag closer to 10k. Which brings us to…..

1.305 H VS2
http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut-loose-diamond-3060894.htm
Size: a 7mm stone! Yipee!
Color and Clarity: H VS2 is likewise mind clean. It's totally eye clean from the top. There is a crystal on the side that could be hidden if positioned properly in the setting.
Idealscope: looks good but does the 1.294 look better?
Cost: I’ll have enough left for a couple of other wish list items.

There is a 1.57 I VS1 that was under consideration but I'm passing due to the following:
*7.5mm, but I'm not sure I'm comfortable sporting that large a rock especially in a setting that will likely be 5mm.
*price eats up my entire budget and I would have to go out of pocket for the setting
*I think the I color would nag me just a bit


Thoughts? On the one hand I prefer the G over H, but there's nothing like being under budget. I wonder if the Idealscope will help settle it?

_15389.jpg

_15390.jpg
 
No bad decision. It seems like it's just a matter of finances. And we can't make that decision for you. That is yours alone. Both stones are gorgeous.
 
Thanks, Gypsy. If you don't see anything to reconsider with these two, I'll drop down to the H. Appreciate your help!
 
Butterflies!!!

I just dropped off the 1.305 H VS2 Expert Select to Bruce Boone via Fedex. It doesn't seem rational to be this excited.

Off topic but what a cool name for a yellow diamond ring: ButterFLY (fancy light yellow).

:appl:
 
The only difference you will see is the color. Aside from budget, you'll have to decide how white you prefer your diamond.
 
I bought the H and it's en route to Bruce to be set.....
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top