Does these 3 stone proportion look okay to you guys?

[move1986]

These three stone have nearly similar diameter of 4.04, 3.96 and 4.21. What do you guys think about 3 stone in similar diameter as oppose to the usual middle with bigger looking stone?

 

[LLJsmom]

These three stone have nearly similar diameter of 4.04, 3.96 and 4.21. What do you guys think about 3 stone in similar diameter as oppose to the usual middle with bigger looking stone?

I've considered that before too. I'm glad I ended up not doing it because I know I wouldn't not have been content with the look for long. I know now why the traditional three stone is preferred.

However, you may find that a three stone with all similar/same size is you. So go for it.

If I were to get a three stone similar in size, the center stone would be a colored stone. I love this one.

http://www.firestoneandparson.com/showitem.php?subcat=9#

 

[move1986]

These three stone have nearly similar diameter of 4.04, 3.96 and 4.21. What do you guys think about 3 stone in similar diameter as oppose to the usual middle with bigger looking stone?

I've considered that before too. I'm glad I ended up not doing it because I know I wouldn't not have been content with the look for long. I know now why the traditional three stone is preferred.

However, you may find that a three stone with all similar/same size is you. So go for it.

If I were to get a three stone similar in size, the center stone would be a colored stone. I love this one.

http://www.firestoneandparson.com/showitem.php?subcat=9#

I know right. Even now i already started to doubt it as the more i look at it the more weird it seems to me with the same diameter of 3 stone ring. I think it will be better off be same size for 5 stone ring. As it is more proportion and full finger coverage.

 

[Niel]

I think if set in this type of three stone you could do it. I'd put the 4.2 one in the middle just to be safe. Or alternatively there are other ways to set three stones together. Like this crazy (cool) one, or like a dinner ring.