Have this diamond on hold for e-ring: Should I purchase?

[Paul777]

Hi everyone,

After searching for a few months and turning away quite a few diamonds, I've learned a lot from this forum and my experiences. I think I have found a diamond which seems to fit the criteria I'm searching for, just not sure about the inclusions on the table. I've attached the GIA certificate, and calculated a 0.9 HCA score.
WIth the diamond currently on hold, any advice would be greatly appreciated. It's priced at $11400 CAD or $10383 USD.
Good deal?
Do you think the diamond would be eye clean considering its a VS2?
Anything I should be worried about or looking at?




I also attached my second choice (a bit above budget @ $10810 USD but also possible). If you think this one is a better choice, let me know also!

http://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/round-cut/1.40-carat-g-color-si1-clarity-excellent-cut-sku-190677

Thanks everyone

 

[Paul777]

... anyone ?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

The GIA report that you posted first goes with the James Allen stone, the SI1. I think it looks really good. I'd have to see the report and pictures of the first stone to compare.

 

[Paul777]

The GIA report that you posted first goes with the James Allen stone, the SI1. I think it looks really good. I'd have to see the report and pictures of the first stone to compare.

The gia report of the first stone is attached, it looks really good aswell, just concerned about the crystal inclusions.

 

[Paul777]

won't let me upload the gia report, but heres a link to it

https://myapps.gia.edu/ReportCheckPortal/getReportData.do?&reportno=2166551032&weight=1.41