help me decide

[woobug02]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOO thank you all so much!!! I think #1 is perfect for the diamond... but love love love the size of #2 and then # 3 makes my diamond look huge but !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

 

[Jenn5504]

Date: 8/23/2007 5:41:39 PM
Author: woobug02
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOO thank you all so much!!! I think #1 is perfect for the diamond... but love love love the size of #2 and then # 3 makes my diamond look huge but !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

EXACTLY..........Where is the 1.6 band (#1) from?

 

[Ellen]

This is funny. I''m normally not a big size gal, and usually less is more with me, so I surprised myself liking 2 so much...


It''s ALL your faults, you''re ruining me.

 

[Ellen]

Date: 8/23/2007 7:27:58 PM
Author: SanDiegoLady

Date: 8/23/2007 11:32:58 AM
Author: Ellen

Date: 8/23/2007 11:29:17 AM
Author: woobug02
side view of 5 stone

Oh yeah, that''s it.

I so totally agree. I love it too. NOW.. if it were eternity...

 

[Rock Candy]

I like #1 the best - they are in the best proportion to your e-ring.

 

[Anastasia]

# 1 Hands down! I think it is the best proportion for your gorgeous e-ring. I think the second one is too large - it distracts from the diamond. I like # 3 also, but I think the proportion of # 1 is perfect.

 

[glitterati]

i LOVE #1!!!!! it really complements your beautiful e-ring!!!

 

[decodelighted]

I think all of them are pretty but if you choose #2 --- make sure the color of the five stones is the same or lower than your e-ring stone. In the pix of #2 ... I see a contrast between the colors that doesn''t flatter your e-ring ... & it''s CLEARLY just the comparison, because your ring looks amazing in all the other pix.

If I was choosing for myself -- I''d be tempted by the bling of #2... but ultimately would choose #3 because of the proportions. The chunkiness of the profile of #1 bothers me a bit, as it pairs up with your solitare.

What a delicious dilemna!!!

 

[risingsun]

I love #2

 

[risingsun]

Date: 8/23/2007 7:27:58 PM
Author: SanDiegoLady

Date: 8/23/2007 11:32:58 AM
Author: Ellen

Date: 8/23/2007 11:29:17 AM
Author: woobug02
side view of 5 stone

Oh yeah, that's it.

I so totally agree. I love it too. NOW.. if it were eternity...

Troublemaker

 

[04diamond<3]

# 2!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[04diamond<3]

Just like to point out that when you talk about the second one, you say "but love love love the size of #2 " so ....I think that''s all that matters!!!!

so yeah...I think if your so in love with it (besides the fact that it makes your diamond and the whole set look AMAZING!!!

) then go for it! You are the one that is going to be wearing it...you might as well have a combination on your hand that makes you happy!!!

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Hi, Woo, sorry to be a day late weighing in here! I also have a solitaire with a diamond band. I have a preference, but I want to ask you a couple of questions first. Refresh my memory on the size of your diamond. Then, what size are the stones in the full eternity #1? Also, who makes #1, and are the stones set low enough that this ring does not stick out further than your e-ring when you look straight down at your finger? I can''t tell that from the pictures. I will say that #3 is way too small for your other ring, and my tendency is to think #2 is too big (a fabulous stand-alone ring, though!), although you can get other similar bands in any size (7 and 9 stone, etc.).

 

[mrssalvo]

I vote number 1...

 

[woobug02]

Wooooo sorry I was out of town for the evening and morning... #1 is from 5th Ave Jewelers... I have purchased many items from them... They do a really nice job.... I am going to post a couple more shots. My ering is 1.61ct. It is I color... The stone seem to match really well however do see in the one photo a little difference. I have been playing with them all week and must make a decision today

here are some more photos

 

[woobug02]

here is #1 eternity band

 

[woobug02]

#1

 

[SuzyQZ]

Woo:

I am shamelessly swayed by the "bling factor" of the five stone.
So #2 is definitely my favorite!

 

[jcrow]

#2 is nice from pics, but having a similar ring, i think the size of the diamonds in #2 would compete too much with the center stone for me personally. i wish i could see these in person! it''s SO hard to pick on based on a 2D picture! that''s why i didn''t respond sooner. i just don''t know which to choose. maybe more pics would help?

 

[woobug02]

5 stone..pictures not that good...

 

[jcrow]

the second pic of the .50 ring looks PERFECT, but it''s so difficult b/c i didn''t love it as a favorite when i saw the first shot of it.

i''m so torn.

 

[woobug02]

Wooo

 

[Sha]

I think #3 complements your engagement ring the best. The other two rings feel like they''re competing for attention wih your e-ring, IMO - especially #2.

 

[angeline]

No 2 ! just seems to sit well and complement perfectly without overpowering imho

 

[ulualoha]

Hi Woobug,

I like 1, so I am kind of in the minority as 2 seems to be the favorite. I just like the fact that I can enjoy both rings on your finger- you can see them both equally and they look lovely together. They are perfectly balanced. I became even more convinced when I saw the pics near your keyboard. I find that the other two combinations of rings the diamond bands are hidden more, even though they are stunning rings. I figure if you are going to wear something that gorgeous, might as well be able to see it and enjoy it.

ulualoha

 

[aljdewey]

I prefer #3 - complimentary and sparkly without upstaging the center stone.

I like more, believe me, but I feel like #2 is just too distracting......takes away from the center stone.

 

[gwendolyn]

I vote for numero uno. The second one''s too big with such a lovely engagement ring stone, and the third one is too small compared to your engagement ring. But the first one is juuuuust riiiiiight.

 

[Tacori E-ring]

I love #3! Makes your diamond look huge. Then I would choose #1, then #2.

 

[iheartscience]

If I have to pick from the 3 pictures, I like #3 the best! #1 is gorgeous, but it takes away from your juicy big center stone, in my opinion! I don''t really like #2 for the same reason and I just don''t like the setting as much as I like the eternity bands.

Now, here''s my proposal for option #4: an eternity band in between the two carat weights of the ones you have. Maybe a .75 ctw eternity? Or even a 1 ctw? I just think #1 is a wee big and #3 could be a wee bigger! I know, I''m difficult!

 

[MaryAlaina]

I like #1 the best (1.60 eternity). I think the 5 stone ring stones are too big and compete with your stone. I like #3, but not as much as #1.