Help Select Stone

[WPMitchell]

Seems there are a lot of helpful, knowledgable people on this forum so I thought I would solicit some assistance selecting a diamond. I am shopping on James Allen. I plan on mounting it on James Allens' white gold Common Prong Engagement Ring with two small side stones on each side. My girlfriend has petit hands and build. We are in are mid-forties and this is a second marriage for both of us. And 7 kids between us so God help me.

My criteria is:
budget: $5000 to $7000
cut: very good or better
color: J-H
clarity: S12-VS2, reasonably eye clean
carat: 1.18-1.34

That narrowed it down to a dizzying number of results. Would anyone care to run the comparisons and give me recommendations?

Thanks in advance.

Warren